|
|
||||||||
a Univ. of Florida, North Florida Research and Education Center, 155 Research Road, Quincy, FL 32351
b Univ. Auburn, Wiregrass Research and Extension Center, 167 Highway 134 East, Headland, AL 36345
* Corresponding author (katsvair{at}ufl.edu)
Received for publication March 23, 2005.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: CRP, Conservation Reserve Program CT, conservation tillage IPM, integrated pest management OM, organic matter SE, Southeast
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A common row crop farming practice in the Southeast (SE) is to grow a two crop rotation of peanuts and cotton and occasionally a small grain winter cover crop for many years under conventional tillage. This traditional system leads to soil degradation and loss of OM (Reeves, 1997; Reddy et al., 2004). Moreover, the sandy soils of the Southeast Coastal Plain are inherently prone to erosion. The high potential for erosion further complicates soil management and results in losses in productivity and environmental pollution. The current system also results in pest and disease buildup and stagnant yields. A USDA (2004a) report showed that peanut and cotton yields in the SE have been stagnant for the past 15 yr although higher-than-normal cotton yields were observed in 2004 and 2005. On the other hand, most beneficial effects of rotations are realized with crop diversification (Elkins et al., 1977; Hagan et al., 2003; Wright et al., 2004; Katsvairo et al., 2004b). We hypothesize that using perennial grasses such as bahiagrass or bermudagrass in the traditional peanutcotton rotation would lead to a rotation that increases yield, improves soil properties, and increases farm profit. Our objectives are to review and address the main production problems in peanut and cotton and evaluate how the use of sod-based rotations, integrated with livestock, could lead to a more sustainable production system with less risk and increased environmental stewardship for the SE. Because current philosophical thinking emphasizes environmental stewardship, our review highlights the potential environmental benefits of the system. Not all details of an integrated crop/sod/livestock cropping systems have been researched extensively, as a result, this review draws inferences in some cases. The review is divided into 2 sections. The first section focuses on diversifying the traditional peanutcotton rotation to include bahiagrass. The second section discusses the benefits of introducing livestock into the bahiagrass/peanut/cotton cropping system.
| CONSERVATION TILLAGE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Peanut
Peanut growers often use clean tillage, which involves several tillage operations on the field. The goal is to completely bury pathogen inoculum which may be present on plant residues, and by doing so, reduce the incidence of soil borne diseases (Sholar et al., 1995; Cox and Scholar, 1995; Johnson et al., 2001). New resistant varieties and fungicides now provide effective control for most peanut soil-borne fungal diseases, enabling peanut growers to use CT techniques (Johnson et al., 2001). Literature, however, shows contrasting reports on how CT affects crop yield compared to conventional tillage practices. While reports exist of lower peanut yields under reduced tillage compared to conventional tillage (Jordan et al., 2001; Grichar, 1998; Brandenburg et al., 1998; Cox and Scholar, 1995), research showing no yield differences between conventional tillage and CT have also been reported (Dowler et al., 1999; Sholar et al., 1993). On the contrary, increased peanut yields under reduced tillage have also been observed (Hartzog et al., 1998; Baldwin and Hook, 1998; Williams et al., 1998). Marois and Wright (2003) not only reported higher peanut yield but also observed reduced disease incidence under CT. Growers in the SE can use CT techniques by using strip till because it is compatible with cotton and peanut production (Pudelko et al., 1995, 1997).
| INCLUSION OF FORAGE GRASSES IN THE PEANUTCOTTON ROTATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the SE, much of the farmland suffers from a natural compaction layer starting at 15- to 20- cm depth and continuing to 30 cm (Kashirad et al., 1967; Campbell et al., 1974). The compaction confines root development to a shallow soil volume and consequently has a major, adverse effect on crop management. The resultant shallow-rooted crops become susceptible to even the smallest amount of moisture stress in the sandy soils typical of the SE. Perennials including bahiagrass and bermudagrass develop a deep root system which penetrates through the compaction layer (Elkins et al., 1977). When the roots die, they decay and leave root channels which impart many positive attributes to soil structure and health (Elkins et al., 1977; Wright et al., 2004). Long and Elkins (1983) compared cotton following 3 yr of continuous bahiagrass sod and continuous cotton. They found a sevenfold increase in pore volume of sizes >1.0 mm in the dense soil layer below the plow depth. They concluded that the dense soil layer had been penetrated by the bahiagrass roots and that, after the decay of the roots, pores were left that were large enough for the cotton roots to grow through.
Perennial grasses including bahiagrass and bermudagrass can reduce the need for irrigation in the following crop. Elkins et al. (1977) calculated that given an evapotranspiration rate of 0.85 cm of water per day, available water of 1 cm per 12 cm of soil, and plant rooting depth of 15 cm, plants will experience water stress after only 3 d without rainfall. However, if the rooting depth was 152 cm, the plant would not experience water stress until 30 d after rainfall (Table 1) (Elkins et al., 1977). Using weather data from Ward et al. (1959), Elkins et al. (1977) determined that for the average Coastal Plain Soil (for the most part a coarse-textured sandy soil with low water-holding capacity), a crop with a rooting depth of 30 cm will experience 60 drought days from May through August in 5 out of 10 yr. However, if rooting depth were 152-cm deep, the crop would experience only 11 drought days. Cropping systems that increase rooting depth and reduce the need for irrigation are essential for water conservation.
|
Organic Matter
Soils in the SE are generally infertile and lower in OM compared those in much of the USA. Continuous row cropping for hundreds of years in many instances has further degraded these delicate soils. Organic matter impacts numerous soil quality factors including improved soil aggregation, water infiltration, acting as a store house for slow release of nutrients and providing substrate to be used by soil fauna including the wide array of microbes and earthworms (Lumbricus terrestris). There has been a progression toward larger and heavier farm machinery in recent years. The heavier machinery can exacerbate compaction problems including the sandy SE soils. Soil OM enables soils to absorb compaction from tillage and harvest equipment (Wilhelm et al., 2004). Historically, agricultural practices that used conventional tillage depleted soil OM, leading to loss in soil productivity. Before intensive farming systems were adopted, native perennial grasses once conserved the soil OM in the former tall prairie grass areas of the USA. The soil OM content was around 4% when it was first plowed out of the native prairie grass and has decreased over the past 100 yr to 1 to 2% through continuous cropping and tillage (Boman et al., 1996). The loss of OM has resulted in the loss of farmers and farmlands (Wright et al., 2003).
Historically, forage legumes have provided more benefits to soil quality and crop yield in the short term than perennial grasses, however, they are not as adapted to the SE where, due to high humidity, they become prone to disease (Gates, 2003). Numerous articles indicate that legumes can immediately increase available N, due to their rapid breakdown and release of N (Vyn et al., 2000; Holderbaum et al., 1990; McVay et al., 1989). Legumes, however, contribute little to long-term build up of soil OM (Frye et al., 1985). In addition to preventing soil losses, the CRP has resulted in increases in OM in the Great Plains (Gebhart et al., 1994). However, the CRP has not always been popular with growers since it takes away farmland that is in close proximity to their farm.
Building up OM levels is a long-term process. Even when the best conservation measures are practiced, OM levels increase at a slow rate of only 0.1 to 0.2% per year (Martin, 2003). Therefore, proper management strategies to prevent soil organic matter depletion should be of foremost importance. Inserting perennial grasses in cropping systems is a favorable and cost-effective way to increase and retain soil OM.
Soil Fauna
Numerous articles cite positive relationships between increased abundance and diversity of soil fauna and soil quality and crop productivity. Soil fauna are responsible for a multitude of soil processes including decay of OM, cycling of nutrients, regulating micro flora through predation, reduction of pest species through predation, breakdown of agricultural chemicals, improvement of soil aggregation, aeration, and water infiltration (Santos and Whitford, 1981; Tabatabai, 1994; Gupta and Yeates, 1997; Doube and Schmidt, 1997; Phelan, 2004; Kennedy et al., 2004). Soil microclimate and niche diversity influence species composition of the soil fauna (van Straalen, 1997). Composite mixtures of plant species favor more microclimates, provide a wider choice of food resources and niches to support a wider faunal species composition (Coll and Bottrell, 1995; Dicke, 1999). Consequently, all agricultural management practices, including the choice of cropping systems, and land preparation, will influence microclimate and hence soil faunal populations (Pankhurst, 1997; Doran and Smith, 1987; Berry and Karlen, 1993; Pankhurst et al., 1995; Kennedy et al., 2004). Diverse crop rotations and reduced tillage are generally believed to increase the number of beneficial soil fauna (Krupinsky et al., 2002; Olfert et al., 2002). Studies have shown an increase in some arthropods and spiders (Blumberg and Crossley, 1983) and ground beetles (House and All, 1981) under CT. Acosta-Martínez et al. (2004) reported higher protozoa and fungi in croplivestock rotations compared to continuous cotton. The authors further concluded that the higher protozoa and fungal densities indicated healthier soil and sustainability of the integrated croplivestock system compared with continuous cotton. In addition to higher productivity, diverse systems have greater resistance (ability to withstands environmental stresses) and resilience (ability to recover from environmental stresses) (Giller et al., 1997; Wolters, 1997; Nicholls and Altieri, 2004). A diversified sod-based bahiagrasscottonpeanut cropping system under CT would be expected to result in rich species compositions of soil flora and fauna. The species composition would be even richer if the sod-based peanutcotton cropping system was coupled with livestock production. Several articles report greater arthropod species diversity in organic farming compared to conventional farming (El Titi and Ipach, 1989; Moreby et al., 1994). A major reason for this is because organic farming maintains high levels of fresh organic matter (Phelan, 2004). Likewise, reduced tillage has more soil dwelling anthropods because of higher organic matter compared to conventional tillage (Olfert et al., 2002). A sodlivestock cropping system would be expected to have higher levels of organic matter, and consequently, improve soil fauna richness. While very little literature exists on the agro-ecological roles soil fauna play in cropping systems (Freckman, 1994; Turco et al., 1994), even less is known about their roles in new cropping systems such as the sod-based peanutcottonlivestock production system.
A group of organisms which has found use in cropping systems as indicators of soil quality and hence sustainability of cropping systems are earthworms. The abundance of earthworms is often correlated with numerous positive soil quality attributes. Earthworms increase aggregate stability (Hopp and Hopkins, 1946), increase soil water infiltration (Trojan and Linden, 1992; Bowman, 1993; Katsvairo et al., 2002), increase the water-holding capacity (Stockdill, 1982), reduce surface crusting (Kladivko et al., 1986), and provide burrows which enable root growth and gaseous exchange. These burrow walls are nutrient rich, thus enhancing nutrient uptake and root growth (Kladivko and Timmenga, 1990; Zachmann and Linden, 1989). Earthworms have the potential to improve compacted soil structure (Lamgmaack et al., 1999) and increase soil aeration (Magdoff and van Es, 2000). Through feeding and burrowing activities and metabolic activities such as excretion and mucus production, earthworms can contribute and cycle nutrients including N and incorporate organic residues and amendments into the soil (Parmelee and Crossley, 1988; Curry et al., 1995; Mackay and Kladivko, 1985; Kladivko et al., 1986). Earthworm castings have also been shown to provide plant growth responses above that of the level of nutrients in the castings (Arancon et al., 2003). Recent findings have shown that the lining of the earthworm channels contain material which enable nitrates and pesticides to be immobilized (Arancon et al., 2003).
Earthworms are sensitive to agricultural management practices including tillage, crop rotations, and pesticides. Numerous studies show that the many forms of CT increase earthworm population densities over conventional tillage. Jordan et al. (1997) compared earthworm densities across several crop rotations and tillage systems. They concluded that tillage was the single most important factor which influences population densities, with no-till having the highest earthworm densities. In another study, Berry and Karlen (1993) showed that the number of earthworms decreased with increase in tillage frequency. Conservation tillage increases plant surface residues, which in turn provides food for the earthworms. Conventional tillage, on the other hand, accelerates decomposition of plant residues and also disrupts earthworm channels. In addition to plant residues, temperature and moisture are also factors that affect earthworm population densities, and both these factors are influenced by tillage practices (Berry and Karlen, 1993).
Very few articles report on the effects of bahiagrass on earthworms in sod-based peanutcotton cropping systems (Hartzog et al., 2005; Wright et al., 2004). Other studies have shown that crop rotations which increase plant residues and OM also increase earthworm population densities (Katsvairo et al., 2002). We expect that a diverse cropping system, which includes bahiagrass in the peanutcotton rotation, would increase plant residues. As shown in previous sections, perennial grasses on their own increased soil OM. Also, growing both peanut and cotton after bahiagrass results in greater biomass from these crops (Katsvairo et al., 2005; Katsvairo et al., 2004b). This too increases the amount of plant residues available for earthworms. Hence, an increase in earthworm population densities would be expected in a diverse rotation which includes bahiagrass. Preliminary studies from Florida and Alabama have shown higher earthworm densities in peanut and cotton after bahiagrass and tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.), (Wright et al., 2004).
| WATER QUALITY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The enforcement of the 1972 Clean Water Act through the Total Maximum Daily Load program, more environmental awareness, government incentives, and fear of lawsuits prompts growers to implement more agricultural practices which could successfully reduce N contamination to the environment. A simple way to reduce N leaching is to reduce application rates, but many farmers fear yield reductions. Historically, the need to guarantee higher yields coupled with the relatively inexpensive price of N fertilizers often caused farmers to apply N at rates greater than crop needs (Hutmacher et al., 2004; Bell et al., 2003). Sexton et al. (1996) showed that very high rates of N caused an exponential increase in N leaching to groundwater.
Growing crops in rotation is an effective way to improve nutrient use efficiency and reduce N leaching. Rotated crops should have different rooting and growth patterns and N demand (Grant et al., 2002). If deep rooted crops such as perennial grasses are included in rotations with shallow rooted crops, the deep rooted crops can scavenge and extract nutrients including N from deep soil profiles and recycle the nutrients that would otherwise have been lost. Also, as described earlier, crops grown after perennial grasses are often more deeply rooted than if they had been grown in continuous cropping. This means subsequent crops after bahiagrass may also extract more N and reduce N-leaching losses. Long and Elkins (1983) found that NO3N in the soil solution at 170-cm depth was only 10 mg L1 in plots following bahiagrass, but 40 mg L1 in plots under continuous cotton (112 kg N ha1 was applied to the cotton crop). In Florida, Katsvairo et al. (2004a) conducted lysimeter studies and reported reduced soil water NO3 and ammonium in cotton grown after bahiagrass compared to cotton in the traditional peanutcotton rotation. In related reports from the same study, the authors documented extensive rooting systems, greater plant biomass, increased leaf area index and nutrient uptake, including N uptake, in the sod-based rotation compared to the conventional system (Katsvairo et al., 2004b, 2005). It seems likely that the reported reduction in soil water N could have been a result of greater N uptake from the cotton when grown after the sod. In Mississippi, a common practice is to reduce N rates by as much as 20% when cotton follows either corn or sorghum (M.W. Ebelhar, personal communication, 2005). The residual N from the N applied for either the corn or sorghum, makes significant contributions to the cotton, a crop which does not require as much N. Reducing N application even by small amounts can have far-reaching positive effects. Sexton et al. (1996) showed that when N application rate was reduced by a mere 5% of the required amount for maximum corn yield, NO3 leaching was reduced by up to 45%.
Phosphorus Considerations
Phosphorus loading is a major environmental concern, with agriculture making a significant contribution to the P in fresh water bodies. Phosphorus accelerates eutrophication, adversely affecting water quality (Sharpley et al., 1994; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1996). An example of a lake adversely affected by eutrophication is Lake Okeechobee in Florida, the largest body of fresh water in the SE (Lake Okeechobee Annual Report, 2004). While concentrations of P as low as 0.02 µg L1 can accelerate eutrophication, P concentrations at Lake Okeechobee are elevated up to 120 µg L1, causing numerous ecological, aesthetic, and economic problems (Sharpley et al., 1993; LakeOkeechobee.org, 2005). Similarly, eutrophication problems as a result of high P levels are also experienced at Lake Opopka, another Florida Lake. Old practices of repumping water back into Lake Okeechobee following furrow irrigation plus erosion are the main causes of the elevated levels of P. In preceding sections we showed that cultural practices such as CT reduce soil erosion, and likewise we also showed that perennial grasses introduced into cropping systems reduce soil erosion. Our data show greater water infiltration rates for the sod rotated cotton compared to conventional cotton (Wright et al., 2004). High infiltration rates reduce runoff losses. We would, therefore, expect that the sod-based peanutcotton cropping system would reduce P contamination to fresh water bodies.
| PEST MANAGEMENT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Weed Considerations
The process of changing from a simple and short-cycle rotational system to a complex multi-crop long rotation may cause weed species shifts, which could be more or less detrimental than the ones they replace (Derksen et al., 2002). We expect the perennial grass rotation to help ameliorate weed problems in crops because in general, diverse cropping systems allow better weed control through the use of broader spectrum of herbicides than simpler rotations (Patterson et al., 1996; Reeves et al., 1996; 1997). Including perennial grasses in rotations provides for longer periods between crops and can effectively break the lifecycles of weeds that mimic the crops (Anderson, 1997; Patriquin, 1988). Once established, perennial grasses are usually competitive and can suppress weed growth. Kalmbacher (1980) reported that bahiagrass suppressed weed encroachment, while Kegode et al. (1999) reported a reduction in weed seed production with perennial grasses. In the case where perennial grasses have slow rates of establishment, and weed control is a major issue during the early stages of establishment, the perennial grasses can be grown in conjunction with other species such as pearl millet [Pennisetum americanum (L.) Leeke], German millet [Setaria italica (L.) Beauv.], and small grains (Wright et al., 1978). These species have aggressive to intermediate rates of establishment. Once the perennial grasses are established, the other species can be mowed down, leaving the perennial grasses to dominate. Diverse cropping systems, as in the case of the bahiapeanutcotton cropping system, have more surface plant residues which can suppress weed growth. The potential for weed suppression is even greater if a burn down herbicide is used on the perennial grass and the subsequent crop is grown under CT. A combination of multiple factors including improved soil structure and efficient utilization of resources can cause subsequent crops after perennial grasses to develop more quickly and rapidly produce a canopy which shades weeds. Rapid canopy development and early season weed suppression has been reported for cotton and peanuts after bahiagrass (Katsvairo et al., 2004b).
Diverse cropping systems support a wider spectrum of weed species (Derksen et al., 1995; Froud-Williams, 1988). Simultaneously, diverse speciation reduces the predominance by any one weed type (Liebman and Dyck, 1993; Anderson, 1998; Derksen et al., 1995). However, if the weed pressure is high, a more diverse weed population may call for more than one type of herbicide, thus increasing herbicide costs. A diverse rotation system spaces out the crops and allows growers to rotate herbicides with different modes of action. This can delay and may prevent the onset of herbicide-resistance in weeds (York and Culpepper, 2004).
| CROP YIELDS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
As with cotton yields, little or no literature documents bahiagrass yields in peanut/cotton cropping systems. Bahiagrass yields up to 13.44 t ha1, and yield can be greater than tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Shreb.), the most widely used pasture crop in the USA, and smooth bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss.), the most used cool-season grass (Field and Taylor, 2002). Its nutritional value, including crude protein (CP), acid detergent fiber (ADF), and neutral detergent fiber (NDF) values are comparable to other grasses (Field and Taylor, 2002). Bahiagrass can be grazed, harvested for seed or hay.
In the SE, peanut and cotton farmers often grow a winter cover crop immediately after harvesting the major row crop. Cover crops are used for winter grazing and to prevent soil erosion, increase soil organic matter and improve soil water retention (Schertz and Kemper, 1994; Bradley, 1993; Nyakatawa et al., 2000; Nyakatawa et al., 2001b; Dabney et al., 2001; Baughman et al., 2001). Cover crops also utilize the residual soil nutrients including N from mineralization of organic matter and reduce leaching losses to groundwater (Brandi-Dohrn et al., 1997; Logsdon et al., 2002). Because cover crops can be drilled directly into winter killed bahiagrass, use of perennial grasses fits with the tradition of using cover crops.
| INTEGRATING LIVESTOCK INTO THE PEANUTCOTTON CROPPING SYSTEM |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| BENEFITS AND CHALLENGES OF INCORPORATING CATTLE INTO THE PEANUTCOTTON ROTATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The National Cattlemen's Beef Association (2004) and Field and Taylor (2002) cite numerous advantages for cattle farming. Row crop farmers too, can take advantage of these benefits if they integrate cattle into their cropping. Below are some of the advantages of grazing cited by the National Cattlemen's Beef Association (2004) and Field and Taylor (2002): prevention of forest fires, control of unwanted vegetation, utilization of plants that cannot be digested by humans, and efficient use of renewable resource i.e., from low-energy grass to high-protein beef.
Bird et al.'s (1995) survey report showed that up to 95% of sustainable farms in four states in the USA had livestock compared to a mere 37 to 58% for conventional farms. A sustainable farm is defined as one which "gives back as much to the land and people as it receives. It seeks independence from non-renewable resources, it minimizes pollution, takes steps to care for the environment, and cares for its employees" (Coffeeresearch.org, 2006). Reasons for including livestock in the rotations included additional weed control through grazing, and higher income from cattle through intensive grazing and winter grazing land that had summer crops. Keeping livestock also provided a cushioning effect in the case where grain which did not attain marketable quality because of weather related reasons could still be fed to livestock.
The ever expanding human population has reduced wildlife habitat. If wildlife populations are going to be sustained, it will be necessary to provide wildlife habitat within agricultural landscapes. Including livestock in cropping systems increases the proliferation of wildlife. The National Cattlemen's Beef Association (2004) reports that ground nesting birds, small mammals and deer (Odocoileus virginianus) find dwelling places in pastures. Ball et al. (1996) documented that the same plant species often grown for livestock in the southern USA are also grown for game animals. Deer, wild turkey (Meleagris gallopavo), and rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) all consume green material. Diverse plants are likely to attract insects, which will in turn attract birds.
In addition to higher returns and environmental stewardship, integrated cropping systems can achieve aesthetic beauty resulting in inner peace for the farmers and surrounding community. Ball et al. (1996) suggested that there is "something restful, peaceful and satisfying in watching animals graze." This is evident in the thousands of pictures and paintings over the centuries which depict pastoral sceneries (Ball et al., 1996). Likewise, pastoral music dates back hundreds of years. Diverse rotation will enable farmers and communities to achieve this artistic beauty.
Incorporating bahiagrasslivestock into the peanutcotton rotation can help sequester C. Estimates show that widespread adoption of pasture-based rotations with CT row crops in the SE could sequester from 13 to 29% of the estimated C potential in the USA (120270 Tg of C) (Causarano et al., 2005). Cropping systems designed to sequester C could also reduce nutrient losses to the environment by 40 to 60% and provide additional potential for participation in environmental trading programs (Causarano et al., 2005).
Integrated farming systems include capability for the components of the system to support each other, and capture additional synergistic effects. In the case of the proposed livestock integrated peanutcotton cropping system, the bahiagrass can be baled and fed to the cattle, or alternatively, the cattle can graze on the bahiagrass. As part of the rotational scheme, cattle can graze on the winter small grain crops. In winter, small grain crops could potentially be grown on land which would be used for peanut and cotton in summer, thus increasing the available pasture land for a higher carrying capacity. Winter cover crops are grown at a time of the year when fewer pests are present. The winter climate of the SE is usually mild with few droughts or floods. Livestock manure from the grazing cattle provides nutrients and other beneficial properties important to soil quality. Gates (2003) reported that livestock manure can increase soil OM content, while Brouwer and Powell (1995; 1998) showed that manure and urine can raise the pH level and accelerate the decomposition of OM. We elaborated on the importance of OM in previous sections.
The on-farm integration of crop and livestock systems is challenging as it requires new knowledge and greater management skills. Most farmers tend to be either good row crop farmers or livestock producers. Hardesty and Tiedeman (1996) pointed out that the safety of some chemicals used on crops has not been determined for livestock. Crops and livestock enterprises can also compete for scarce resources including land and labor. A recent drop in grain crop prices in Argentina prompted farmers to rebuild their cattle herds on the land which decades ago was in pastures but was recently in field crops. The farmers encountered competition for land between the two enterprises, making it difficult to return to livestock production (Arzadun et al., 2003).
More potential downfalls exist in having livestock in integrated cropping systems. Grazing by cattle can cause soil compaction which in turn can reduce water infiltration and increase soil bulk density. Profitt et al. (1993) showed that animal hooves can exert pressures as high as 200 kPa. Compaction on the other hand is a function of soil texture and moisture, grazing intensity, vegetation and climate (Taboada and Lavado, 1993). Studies from Alabama have shown that animal grazing causes compaction mostly in the top 15 cm of the soil, but little below that depth (Katsvairo et al., unpublished data, 2004). Krenzer et al. (1989) and Worrell et al. (1992) both reported an increase in soil compaction on the subsequent winter wheat as a result of grazing. Increased compaction could have partially caused the crop yield reduction they observed. On a silt loam soil in Alabama, Mullins and Burmester (1997) observed a reduction in cotton yield in 2 of 3 yr after grazing a wheat cover crop. Abdel-Magid et al. (1987) reported an increase in bulk density in the 0- to 5-cm depth due to cattle grazing in 1 of 2 yr.
Other researchers have shown that the damage due to animal compaction is minimal and short lived. Twerdoff et al. (1999) found that the bulk density increase on loamy soil as a result of animal treading was lower in perennial pastures compared to annual pastures. Mapfumo et al. (1999) reported that cyclical perturbations such as wetting and drying and earthworm activities can alleviate the impacts of compaction. Russell et al. (1999) reported an increase in soil bulk density and surface roughness after grazing corn residues, however, this did not decrease the subsequent soybean yields in a soybeancorn rotation. Siri-Prieto et al. (2003) observed an increase in compaction in the 10- to 15-cm depth as a result of grazing but concluded that conventional tillage or CT with noninversion deep tillage can reverse and negate the problem.
Cattle manure may be substituted for chemical fertilizers. In addition to providing plant nutrients, animal manure provides physical, chemical, and biological benefits to the soil beyond that of inorganic commercial fertilizers (Hatfield and Cambardella, 2001). In pastures, cattle feces can be an important source of nutrients. However, not all the deposited nutrients are taken up by plants and can be a source of nonpoint-source pollution and hazardous to the environment (White et al., 2001). Nonetheless, pasture-based cattle systems require less-expensive manure management systems compared with confinement dairy farms (White et al., 2001). In fact, Naylor et al. (2005) further points out that delinking crop and livestock production systems increases both N and P runoff.
| ECONOMICS OF THE CROPLIVESTOCK SYSTEM |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Despite the apparent increase in profits in the long run, adoption is expected to be slow for the sod rotation cropping system. Currently only 2% of the peanuts produced in Florida are preceded by bahiagrass. Also about 80% of the land under peanut and cotton in Florida is rented and the majority on a yearly basis. Growers are thus forced operate based on short-term economic gains and not for long term. However, as growers learn that profits can be higher in mixed croplivestock systems requiring that less than half the acreage be in crops, adoption of the system should increase.
| CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The cropsodlivestock rotation, particularly under CT, shows great potential for the SE. Conservation tillage reduces production costs and improves soil and water quality. Inclusion of perennial grasses in the cropping system adds to the benefits accruing for the implementation of CT alone and should further enhance soil and water quality. A sod-based rotation should reduce reliance on irrigation, pesticides, and the reduction in row-crop hectares should reduce the need for large equipment. Crop yields after perennial grasses are increased. Cattle diversify marketable products and create an alternate source of crop utilization, while reducing overall risks compared to farming operations based solely on row crops. Development of an effective sod-based livestock integrated cropping system is an economically and ecologically viable alternative to the current peanutcotton cropping system. Sod-based rotations are applicable to a wide range of soil types, are an effective practice to control plantparasitic nematodes and plant diseases, and reduce overall pest problems. By increasing farm profitability by two- to sixfold, this system could also help improve rural economics. Researchers in the tri-states (Alabama, Florida, and Georgia) are currently conducting cooperative work to test the viability of the cropsodlivestock enterprise. This extensive research evaluates soil quality, plant development, weeds, insects, and disease, yield and livestock performance and economics in the new cropping system. To date, soil quality, plant development, yield, disease and pest control, and economic returns data from this multi-state study have been positive and encouraging. We are seeing positive ripple effects within the system where the positive effects of bahiagrass on soil quality are resulting in plants with higher growth rates and ability to better withstand environmental stresses. Improved growth is translating into higher yields with reduced usage of pesticides. The effects cumulate to create higher economic returns compared with monocultures. Much remains unknown, and hence, there is the need for more research. The performance of the cotton and peanut in rotation with perennial grasses under different environmental conditions to include different rainfall regimes and different soil types is largely unknown. Most of the management techniques currently used in the management of the sod-based livestockcropping systems are derived either from cotton, peanut, or cattle management systems. There is a need to develop management techniques specifically tailored for the integrated peanutcotton livestock-based production systems. It is unknown whether there is a need to develop different fertilization rates which take into consideration nutrient recovery with perennial grasses. Should new cotton and peanut varieties be developed for the sod-based systems? Furthermore, the sod-based system could be integrated with more modern techniques such as precision agriculture. However, this system holds great promise for both the sustainability and profitability for many years into the future.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|