|
|
||||||||
Crop Genetics and Production Research Unit, Box 345, Stoneville, MS 38776
* Corresponding author (abruns{at}ars.usda.gov).
Received for publication May 13, 2005.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: GDU 10, growing degree unit based on 10°C
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Research from the Corn Belt on planting dates has shown only slight or no yield reductions occur when seeding is done before the determined optimum date, but late planting can be detrimental (Nafziger, 1994; Johnson and Mulvaney, 1980; Lauer et al., 1999; Carter, 1984; Swanson and Wilhelm, 1996). In Illinois, Nafziger (1994) found corn yields generally increased as planting was delayed from 10 to 30 April, but then steadily declined from 9 to 29 May. Earlier, Johnson and Mulvaney (1980) found the optimum planting date in central Illinois was 6 May, and that planting 2 wk before or after that date reduced yields <5%. However, a rapid decline in grain yield occurred if planting was delayed past 20 May. Though the optimum planting dates differed, Lauer et al. (1999) later reported similar results from research at several locations in Wisconsin. In Wisconsin average grain yields for corn hybrids of similar maturities declined 31% when planting was delayed from 1 May to 1 June (Carter, 1984). Bauer and Carter (1986) later determined delaying planting from 1 to 30 May, for several hybrids of different maturities, resulted in increased levels of kernel breakage during handling. In simulated no-till planting conditions, Swanson and Wilhelm (1996) reported planting corn before or after the optimum date resulted in reduced leaf area index, leaf area duration, total dry matter production, and grain yield. Yields declined with both earlier and later planting dates but declined more rapidly when planting was delayed than when it was advanced.
Hybrid Bt corns have changed the management of the crop throughout the USA. When planting is delayed, Bt corn hybrids are often recommended over non-Bt hybrids to avoid yield losses that frequently occur due to feeding by several lepidopteran insects species (VanDyk, 2002; Flanders et al., 1999; Buntin et al., 2001; Wiatrak et al., 2004). VanDyk (2002) stated Bt hybrid corn should not be intentionally planted "late" but planting such hybrids last during the spring planting sequence provides the best opportunity for an economic benefit of growing them rather than non-Bt hybrids. Flanders et al. (1999) reported that in Alabama, Bt hybrids have a decided advantage in yield over non-Bt hybrids when grown in the southern part of the state. However, in central and northern sites such an advantage existed only when planting occurred late. Buntin et al. (2001) found Bt hybrids had reduced ear infestation of fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda J.E. Smith) and corn earworm (Helicoverpa zea Boddie) larvae resulting in less kernel damage and thus greater grain yields than was observed in non-Bt hybrids. Wiatrak et al. (2004) reported insect feeding and disease contributed to grain yield declines in both Bt and non-Bt genotypes as planting was delayed. However, smaller yield reductions due to late planting were noted in Bt hybrids compared with non-Bt hybrids.
Mycotoxins can be a serious problem in corn, particularly in crops grown in the southern USA. The economic losses and expenditures in research and monitoring mycotoxins in all crops grown in the USA are estimated at between $0.5 and $1.5 billion annually (Robens and Cardwell, 2003). Drought and heat stress in 1977 and 1978 resulted in nearly 90% of the corn crop grown in South Carolina being contaminated with aflatoxin, a mycotoxin produced by the fungus Aspergillus flavus (Manwiller and Fortnum, 1979). Losses to aflatoxin in Texas, Arkansas, Mississippi, and Louisiana in 1998 were estimated to be $85 million (U.S.) (Williams et al., 2003; Abbas et al., 2002, 2005). Williams et al. (2004) later concluded that in areas with high southwestern cornborer (Diatraea grandiosella Dyar) infestations, Bt hybrids should effectively reduce aflatoxin contamination, but the reduction is due to control of the insects and not to any resistance to A. flavus.
Fumonisin, a mycotoxin produced by the fungus Fusarium moniliforme J. Sheld., is known to cause several diseases in livestock (Bruns, 2003). Corn with Bt genes has been shown to experience less Fusarium infection because of the association between the fungus and insect feeding (Munkvold et al., 1997). Hammond et al. (2004) observed lower levels of fumonisin in Bt hybrids than non-Bt hybrids and concluded the use of Bt hybrids can increase the percentage of corn grain that would be suitable for use in food and feed.
Planting date has been shown to facilitate mycotoxin contamination (Bruns, 2003). The general conclusion is planting should be done so that reproductive growth of the crop avoids as much drought and heat stress as possible. Current information on planting dates of newer hybrids with varying maturities and with Bt and non-Bt genetics is very limited for the Mid-South, USA. The objective of this research was to examine effects of varying planting dates on the agronomics of both Bt and non-Bt hybrids of different maturity ratings grown using furrow irrigation in the Mid-South. Growing degree units using a 10°C base (GDU 10's) for growth stage R1 (silking) and growth stage R6 (physiological maturity) as defined by Ritchie et al. (1997), yield, yield components, grain bulk density, lodging, and mycotoxin contamination are reported.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Date of growth stage R1and growth stage R6 (physiological maturity) was determined for each experimental unit. These data were combined with weather data collected at the research station (Mississippi State Univ., 2005) to determine GDU 10's as previously described (Bruns and Abbas, 2005; Shaw, 1988). During reproductive growth the center 5.2 m of the two middle rows of each experimental unit were identified, and the end plants marked with flagging tape. Plant populations for each experimental unit were determined by counting plants within the marked areas. Just before harvests, these same areas were reexamined and counts made on any lodged plants and/or dropped ears. Individual experimental units were harvested beginning about 28 d after growth stage R6 (Bruns and Abbas, 2004). Ears of plants contained between marked sections of each experimental unit were hand harvested, then shelled using an Almaco1 (Allen Machine Co., Nevada, IA) gasoline-powered corn sheller, and the grain weighed. A sample of approximately 1.0 kg of grain was taken to determine moisture content, grain bulk density, kernel weight, and mycotoxin contamination in each experimental unit. Grain moisture content and bulk density were determined using a Seedboro1 Model GMA 128 Grain Moisture Analyzer (Seedboro Equipment Co., Chicago, IL). Grain yields were adjusted and reported at a moisture level of 155 g kg1.[CONVERTED 1:1 TO PER-KG] Grain samples were then dried at 30°C for 18 h. Kernel weights for each experimental unit were determined by hand counting and weighing 100 sound kernels. Kernels ear1 were estimated by dividing harvested grain weight per experimental unit, adjusted for moisture content, by population data, assuming one ear plant1, and then dividing that product by the kernel weight.
Aflatoxin and fumonisin contamination levels were determined using Veratox1Aflatoxin and Veratox1Fumonisin Kits (Neogen Co., Lansing, MI), respectively. Specific procedures used for mycotoxin determinations have been previously published by Abbas et al. (2002).
Statistical analyses on grain yields, yield components, GDU 10's, and fumonisin contamination were performed on data combined over years using procedures outlined by McIntosh (1983), treating years as random effects and using PROC MIXED of the SAS procedure (SAS Institute, 2004). Pearson's correlations were calculated on some GDU 10 data. Data on GDU 10's were also analyzed for individual years and due to a lack of homogeneity, data on aflatoxin was analyzed and reported for individual years.
| RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
0.1 plant per experimental unit). The mean maximum temperature for April 2002 was below normal while all other mean maximum temperatures during the experiment were normal (Table 2). Rainfall totals during June 2003 and June 2004 were above normal due to two large rain events in June 2003 and an unusually wet period during the last week of June 2004.
|
0.10) for early April and late April plantings than mid-May plantings (Tables 3 and 4). These observations are similar to previously reported data from the Corn Belt with regard to yield and planting date (Nafziger, 1994; Johnson and Mulvaney, 1980; Lauer et al., 1999; Carter, 1984; Swanson and Wilhelm, 1996). Grain moisture at harvest, mean kernels ear1, kernel weights, and grain bulk density did not differ among the three planting dates (Tables 3 and 4).
|
|
0.01) than those of short-season hybrids (Tables 3 and 5). These data are similar to earlier research (Bruns and Abbas, 2005). Grain bulk densities for short-season hybrids 8830 and 9185Bt were below the 695 kg m3 minimum requirement for U.S. no. 2 yellow corn, the most common grade traded on the world market, and would have likely been docked in price when sold (USDA, 1996).
|
0.05) only for A6729Bt than all the earlier maturing hybrids in the experiment. Conversely both 8830 and A6257 had less (P
0.05) grain moisture at harvest than most of the later maturing hybrids. The low grain moisture levels observed for these two non-Bt hybrids was the likely reason greater (P
0.01) grain moisture levels were observed for the Bt hybrids than the non-Bt hybrids when averaged among all years and planting dates (Table 6). From a production standpoint, however, these differences would be minor and would not likely affect the price received for the grain on the market.
|
0.01) grain yields than non-Bt hybrids (Table 6). This resulted from the Bt hybrids averaging more (P
0.01) kernels ear1 that weighed more (P
0.01). However, unlike previous research, Bt hybrids in this experiment did not yield more grain than non-Bt hybrids when planted late (mid-May) (Table 3). No differences in mean grain bulk density were observed between Bt and non-Bt hybrids. With exception of 9185Bt, all Bt hybrids yielded more grain than at least one non-Bt hybrid in their respective maturity group (Table 5). It cannot be stated these differences were due to less insect damage to the Bt hybrids because such data were not collected in this experiment. However, other studies have shown yield advantages for Bt hybrids over non-Bt genotypes that were related to less insect feeding on developing kernels (Flanders et al., 1999; Buntin et al., 2001; VanDyk, 2002; Wiatrak et al., 2004). Fall armyworm, corn earworm, and southwestern corn borer (Diatraea grandiosella Dyar) are known to reduce corn yields in the Mid South USA (C.A. Abel, personnel communication, 2005).
With exception of A6333Bt, both full-season and mid-season hybrids produced more grain than short-season hybrids in this experiment (Table 4). Averaged among all years and planting dates, short-season hybrids produced fewer (P
0.01) kernels ear1 (458 vs. 523 and 539 for full-season and mid-season hybrids, respectively) that weighed less (P
0.01) (268 mg vs. 279 mg and 285 mg, respectively, for full-season and mid-season hybrids). Corn hybrids that utilize the greatest amount of the growing season generally yield more grain than those requiring fewer GDU 10's to reach growth stage R6 (Poehlman, 1959, p. 263; Larson, 2002a). However, Bruns and Abbas (2005) recently reported some modern short-season corn hybrids when grown in the Mid South USA using furrow irrigation, produce comparable yields to full-season and mid-season hybrids.
The GDU 10's required to achieve both growth stage R1 and growth stage R6, differed among hybrids of this experiment (Tables 3 and 5). Except for A6333Bt, short-season hybrids of this study required fewer GDU 10's (P
0.01) to achieve growth stage R1 than mid-season and full-season hybrids. For short-season hybrids, the GDU 10's required to reach growth stage R6 were greater than the stated requirement found in company sales literature, when grown in their adapted environments (Tables 1 and 5). Similar findings have been previously reported (Bruns and Abbas, 2005). Two mid-season hybrids (34B23 and 34B24Bt) and two full-season hybrids (A6670 and A6729Bt) required more GDU 10's to achieve growth stage R6 than any short-season hybrid except A6257 (Table 5). The short-season hybrid 9185Bt, which was one of the lower yielding hybrids in the experiment and also the only Bt hybrid not to yield more grain than at least one non-Bt hybrid in its maturity range, also had the least GDU 10 requirement to achieve growth stage R1 and one of the least to achieve R6 (Table 5).
The GDU 10's accumulated at growth stages R1 and R6, when analyzed by individual years, differed significantly (P
0.01) between planting dates all 3 yr but, no trend existed for any 2 yr (data not shown). When combined over years, no differences in GDU 10 requirements at any planting date neither growth stage R1 nor R6 were observed (Table 3).
Grain yields of hybrids in this experiment were found to be correlated (P
0.01) to GDU 10's required to achieve growth stage R1 [yield = 0.0371x 20.416 (r = 0.77)]. However, no correlation with yield and growth stage R6 was evident. Grain yield was also found to be correlated (P
0.01) to kernels ear1 (y = 0.0128x + 2.0737, r = 0.74) while no relationship was observed between yield and kernel weights. These data indicate the period of growth in which potential kernels ear1 was being determined (growth stage V12 to growth stage R1) was more critical to grain yield in this experiment than the period of kernel filling (growth stage R2 to growth stage R6) (Ritchie et al., 1997). In the Mid-South USA a greater potential exists for heat and drought stress during growth stages R1 to R6 than during growth stages before R1 (Boykin et al., 1995). Drought and heat stress encountered during growth stages R2 to R6 most likely diminish the probability of detecting any potential relationship between GDU 10's required for physiological maturity (R6) and grain yield.
Mean aflatoxin contamination levels differed extensively among years (Table 7). Heat stress during kernel filling favors A. flavus infection and subsequent aflatoxin production (Bruns, 2003). Total days with maximum temperatures 32°C during June and July, when the bulk of kernel filling was occurring in all planting dates, was 41 in 2002 and 30 for both 2003 and 2004 (Mississippi State Univ., 2005).
|
0.01) aflatoxin contamination than the non-Bt hybrids in 2003 (12.4 mg Mg1 vs. 45.3 mg Mg1, respectively), but no such differences were noted in the other 2 yr. Full-season hybrids had more (P
0.01) aflatoxin contamination in 2002 than the mid-season or short-season hybrids (Table 7). No such differences were noted in the two succeeding years. Aflatoxin levels among individual hybrids were found not to differ.
Data on grain contamination by fumonisin did not vary among years and therefore were combined and analyzed. Non-Bt hybrids averaged among all years and planting dates had greater (P
0.01) amounts of fumonisin grain contamination than Bt hybrids (Table 6). As previously stated, insect damage was not quantified in this study. However, lower levels of fumonisin in Bt hybrids have previously been reported (Hammond et al., 2004).
| CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mid-season hybrids appear to yield as well as full-season hybrids in the lower Mississippi River Valley. One short-season hybrid (A6333 Bt) in this experiment yielded as well as most of the mid-season and full-season hybrids. Grain bulk density of two of the short-season hybrids was below the minimum standard for no. 2 yellow corn and would have been docked in price when sold.
These data indicate that, using current plant populations, corn yields in the Mid-South and any possible genotypic differences in yield are influenced most by environmental conditions during growth stages when the kernels ear1 are being determined. Potential genotypic differences in kernel filling are likely being masked by drought and/or heat stress in the region that is more probable during those growth stages (R2R6) (Boykin et al., 1995). Additional heat stress during these growth stages in 2002 appears to have also greatly increased aflatoxin contamination. Such an increase has been demonstrated by others in previous research (Manwiller and Fortnum, 1979; Williams et al., 2003).
The Bt hybrids have a yield advantage over the non-Bt hybrids by producing more kernels ear1 as well as less fumonisin contamination. However, only in 2003 did the Bt hybrids have less aflatoxin.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| NOTES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 Mention of a trade name, proprietary product, or specific equipment does not constitute a guarantee or warranty by the USDA-ARS and does not imply approval of the named product to the exclusion of other similar products. ![]()
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. J. Kucharik Contribution of Planting Date Trends to Increased Maize Yields in the Central United States Agron. J., February 26, 2008; 100(2): 328 - 336. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. R. Capristo, R. H. Rizzalli, and F. H. Andrade Ecophysiological Yield Components of Maize Hybrids with Contrasting Maturity Agron. J., June 26, 2007; 99(4): 1111 - 1118. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
X. Y. Sha and S. D. Linscombe Planting Date Affects Grain and Milling Yields of Water-Seeded Clearfield Rice Agron. J., June 26, 2007; 99(4): 1143 - 1150. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. J. Kucharik A Multidecadal Trend of Earlier Corn Planting in the Central USA Agron. J., October 3, 2006; 98(6): 1544 - 1550. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. F. Stanger and J. G. Lauer Optimum Plant Population of Bt and Non-Bt Corn in Wisconsin Agron. J., June 5, 2006; 98(4): 914 - 921. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Crop Science | Vadose Zone Journal | |||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Soil Science Society of America Journal | ||||
| Journal of Plant Registrations | Journal of Environmental Quality |
The Plant Genome | |||