|
|
||||||||
a Dep. of Agron., Iowa State Univ., Ames, IA 5001
b Dep. of Stat., Iowa State Univ., Ames, IA 5001
* Corresponding author (lgibson{at}iastate.edu)
Received for publication August 30, 2002.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The potential of eastern gamagrass for pastures, cut forage, and conservation has been well documented, but there are several factors currently limiting its adoption. Poor stand establishment resulting from seed dormancy remains one of the greatest factors. Seed viability is generally high, but laboratory germination of dry, intact, and cupulated seed is often less than 10%. Cold, moist stratification has been recommended and adopted as practice for breaking eastern gamagrass seed dormancy (Ahring and Frank, 1968), but there are several associated problems. Seed must be stratified for 6 wk before planting (by either the seed supplier or the person planting it). Stratification requires appropriate facilities, and the seed must be kept cold during shipping. Once the seed is stratified, it must be stored cold to prevent heating and desiccation. Moist seed also complicates the planting operation because it does not flow through a drill or planter as freely as dry seed.
Many groups including the USDA-NRCS (1986, 2002), some state extension services (Ohlenbusch and Kilgore, 1999; Roberts 1991), and seed producers (Anonymous, 1999b) have developed planting guidelines for eastern gamagrass. Winter plantings may be one of the more successful practices for establishing eastern gamagrass because winter conditions trigger natural processes that break seed dormancy (Ahring and Frank, 1968; Anderson, 1985). Many of these recommendations appear to be based on experiential knowledge and studies of cold, moist stratification on germination and emergence.
Mueller et al. (2000) reported significantly greater stand establishment of eastern gamagrass in North Carolina with November through February plantings than March and April plantings. These results provide satisfactory recommendations for planting of eastern gamagrass in areas with moderate winter temperatures. However, they are not sufficient for northern areas of eastern gamagrass adaptation because soils are typically frozen during the November to February period. In addition, production of full-season summer annual crops in much of the U.S. Corn Belt often limits the amount of time available for establishment of forage and conservation plantings in the spring and fall months. The objectives of this study were to determine the best procedures and provide recommendations for planting eastern gamagrass in the northern range of its adaptation.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The experimental areas were previously in a corn (Zea mays L.)soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] rotation, with corn in 1998 and soybean in 1997. The experimental areas were soil-tested on 19 Nov. 1998 and contained 30 mg kg-1 P, 200 mg kg-1 K, 58.5 g kg-1 organic matter, and a buffer pH of 6.6. They were limed on 2 Dec. 1998 to bring the soil pH to 6.8. Nineteen ninety-nine was a fallow year in preparation for the experiments. Field preparation included two double-disking operations, followed by field cultivation. A John Deere Model 71 Flexi-Unit planter with double-disc openers (Deere & Co., Moline, IL) was used to plant. Depth bands were used to precisely control the planting depth. The seed was planted in rows spaced at 76.2 cm at a rate of 15.7 seeds m-1 row in plots that were four rows wide and 6.1 m long. The plots received no fertilization during the experiments. AAtrex 4L {atrazine[6-chloro-N-ethyl-N'-(1-methylethyl)-1,3,5-triazine-2,4-diamine]} (Syngenta Crop Protection, Greensboro, NC) was surface-applied for weed control at 2.05 kg ha-1 a.i. on 5 May 2000 and 10 May 2001. The plots were hand-weeded as needed throughout the duration of the experiment.
Seed of Pete eastern gamagrass used for this experiment was purchased from Gamagrass Seed Co., Falls City, NE. Seed planted in Year 1 was harvested in 1998, and seed planted in Year 2 was harvested in 1999. Seed (0.7 kg) for the cold, moist stratification treatment was placed in a cloth bag, soaked in 1 L of 2.5 g kg-1 thiram [bis(dimethylthiocarbamoyl) disulfide] solution, drained after 24 h, and placed in cold storage for 6 wk at 4°C and 40% relative humidity. Unstratified seed was continuously stored dry in 4°C and 40% relative humidity until planting.
A standard germination test, with three replicates, was begun on both stratified and unstratified seed on the day of each planting. Fifty seeds were placed in 13- by 13- by 3.5-cm covered containers containing two layers of Anchor Steel Blue seed germination paper (Anchor Paper Co., St. Paul, MN) moistened with distilled water. The tests were performed at alternating temperature of 20 and 30°C (Ahring and Frank, 1968) with light supplied by four 40-W cool-white fluorescent lights vertically oriented on both the left and right sides of the germinator and 30°C for 8 h daily. Germination counts were made every 7 d for 28 d. Seeds were considered germinated if the coleoptile exceeded the seed in length and the seedling was normal according to the seedling evaluation criteria of AOSA for comparable grasses (AOSA, 1992). Normal seedlings were removed as they were counted. Water was added to each germination box as needed to maintain optimum moisture levels. After 28 d of incubation, ungerminated seeds were examined by tetrazolium (TZ) tests (AOSA, 1998) and classified as dormant or dead.
In the field studies, total live seedlings, newly emerged seedlings, and newly dead seedlings were counted weekly during the growing season. A seedling was considered emerged when it was about 3.0 cm in height and visually discernable from other grass seedlings. Seedlings were considered dead when they wilted, became completely chlorotic, and showed no sign of recovery. The total number of live seedlings at 1 yr after planting was converted to a percentage of the total number of seeds planted per plot and reported as net seedling survival. Accumulated emergence over the first year after planting was calculated by adding each week's newly emerged seedlings to the accumulated emergence for the previous week and converting to a percentage of the total of number of seeds planted per plot. Seedling mortality was calculated by dividing the total number of seedlings that died in the first year after planting by the total number of plants emerging in each plot during this period and converting to a percentage. Because of considerable emergence in the second year following planting, net seedling survival and mortality counts were taken on 28 May and 11 June 2002 for the 17 Apr. 2000 and 15 May 2000 plantings, respectively. Precipitation (Fig. 1) and temperature (Fig. 2) were monitored at the Iowa State University AgronomyAgricultural and Biosystems Engineering Farm approximately 2 km northwest of the experiment site.
|
|
Statistical analysis of emergence rate was performed using tests for equality of survival curves (Hosmer and Lemeshow, 1999). Replicates of each treatment (combination of planting date, planting depth, and seed treatment) were summed to define a cohort of individuals. To compare rates of emergence between treatments, the weekly counts of newly emerged seedlings were used to compute the time from planting to emergence for every ungerminated seed. The time to emergence for seeds that did not germinate was a censored value (an unknown value longer than the length of the study) (Dixon and Newman, 1991). The null hypothesis that treatments have the same emergence curves was tested using the nonparametric log-rank test (Hosmer and Lemeshow, 1999) computed using the LIFETEST procedure in SAS.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Although the planting date x depth interaction for net seedling survival was significant in both study years, very few differences in net seedling survival between the 2.5- and 5.0-cm planting depths were found when the effects of planting depth were analyzed at each planting date. The shallower depth resulted in greater net seedling survival in the 16 June 2000 and 15 Aug. 2000 plantings but less net seedling survival in the 1 Nov. 1999 planting (Fig. 3).
Accumulated Seedling Emergence and Seedling Mortality
The final net seedling survival (total number of live plants at 1 yr after planting) was a function of the accumulated seedling emergence (Fig. 4 and 5) and seedling loss through mortality (Fig. 6). Accumulated emergence was monitored with weekly stand counts after planting. When the emergence curves were statistically analyzed for each planting date using tests for equality of survival curves (Hosmer and Lemeshow, 1999), differences among treatments were significant at P > 0.001, except 17 Apr. 2001, which was not significant.
|
|
|
Tests for equality of survival curves were made for the emergence curves of the two stratification treatments at each planting date and depth combination. For 19992000, the curves were statistically different for all of the planting date and depth combinations except the 2.5- and 5.0-cm depths planted on 16 June (Fig. 4 and 5). In the 16 August planting, emergence from stratified seed was greater than unstratified seed in the weeks immediately after planting. However, there were greater amounts of emergence of unstratified seed in the following spring. Emergence from the 1 November planting did not begin until the following spring, and unstratified seed produced greater emergence than stratified seed. Emergence in the planting season was greater for stratified seed in the 14 April and 15 May plantings. Great amounts of emergence from the unstratified seed in the spring following planting resulted in similar accumulated emergence at 1 yr after planting in the stratified and unstratified seed planted on 15 May.
Accumulated emergence was greater at 5.0 than 2.5 cm for the 1 November stratified and unstratified plantings and the 14 April unstratified plantings. In contrast, emergence was greater at 2.5 than 5.0 cm for the 16 June plantings of stratified and unstratified seed.
Main effects of planting date and stratification treatment on seedling mortality in the first year after planting were great in 19992000 (Table 1). In addition, the planting date x stratification interaction was significant. Seedling mortality was above 40% in the 16 August and 1 November plantings of both stratified and unstratified seed and the 14 April planting of stratified seed (Fig. 6). It was below 30% in the 14 April planting of unstratified seed and the 15 May and 16 June plantings of both stratified and unstratified seed. Seedlings from stratified seed had increased mortality compared with unstratified seed for 16 August, 14 April, and 16 June plantings but not the 1 November and 15 May plantings.
The relative contributions of accumulated emergence and seedling mortality to net seedling survival of the 19992000 plantings varied by planting date. Net seedling survival for the 16 August planting was greater for unstratified than stratified seed because emergence was greater and mortality was less for the unstratified seed. In the 1 November planting of unstratified seed, mortality was similar for the two planting depths, but emergence was less at 2.5 than 5.0 cm. Accumulated emergence and seedling mortality were similar for the 2.5- and 5.0-cm stratified plantings on 1 November. Net seedling survival for the 14 April planting of stratified seed was more than double that of unstratified seed because emergence was more than three times greater for the stratified seed. However, greater seedling mortality in the stratified seed somewhat diminished the emergence advantage. For the 15 May planting, net seedling survival, accumulated emergence, and mortality were similar in all of the stratification and planting depth combinations. The 2.5-cm unstratified planting had the greatest net seedling survival of the 16 June plantings. It had greater amounts of emergence than the other three plantings and less mortality than the 2.5- and 5.0-cm stratified plantings.
In 20002001, accumulated emergence at 1 yr after planting was 41% for unstratified seed compared with 36% for stratified seed when averaged across the five planting dates. There were no significant effects for planting date or the planting date x stratification interaction.
Emergence curves for unstratified and stratified seeds were statistically different in all planting date and depth combinations except 5.0 cm planted on 15 August and 2.5 and 5.0 cm planted on 17 April. Emergence in the spring following planting was greater for the unstratified than stratified seed in the 15 August planting at 2.5 cm and 31 October plantings at both depths. For the 15 May and 15 June plantings, the emergence during the season that the seed was planted was greater for stratified than the unstratified seed. Ultimately, the unstratified seed produced greater accumulated emergence at 1 yr after planting in the 15 May planting because a greater number of seedlings emerged from the unstratified seed in the spring following planting. Similarly, emergence in the second season from unstratified seed resulted in similar amounts of accumulated emergence at 1 yr after planting for the stratified and unstratified seed planted on 15 June. The emergence curves for planting depth were different for stratified seed planted on 15 August and unstratified seed planted on 15 August and 31 October. In all three of these situations, the 2.5-cm planting depth resulted in greater emergence.
Because planting date did not influence accumulated emergence at 1 yr after planting, seedling mortality was the major determinate of differences in net seedling survival among planting dates in 20002001. Seedling mortality was greater than 30% in the 17 April and 15 May plantings, about 22% in the 15 June planting, and below 5% in the August and November plantings. Stratified seed had greater seedling mortality than unstratified seed in the 17 April plantings but lower mortality in the 15 May planting. Seedling mortality of the 15 August, 31 October, and 15 June plantings was not affected by stratification. Planting depth had no effect on seedling mortality of any of the planting dates in 20002001.
In both study years, emergence generally began about 4 wk after the April plantings and 3 wk after planting in the other months. Plants appeared over a 6- to 9-wk period for the April, May, and June plantings. Most plantings had some seedling emergence in the second growing season after planting. These plants generally appeared over a 2- to 4-wk period beginning the first week of May. The exceptions were the August and November plantings in 1999, in which completion of spring emergence took about 8 wk. Rate of emergence was generally unaffected by planting depth but appeared to be more rapid with stratified than unstratified seed for the 16 Aug. 1999, 16 June 2000, and 17 Apr. 2001 plantings.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We did have one situation were fall planting of unstratified seed was ineffective. The low emergence in 2.5-cm plantings made on 1 Nov. 1999 likely resulted from dry, windy weather conditions the following spring when seeds began germinating and plants were first emerging. The warm winds dried out the topsoil and resulted in considerable soil movement in the plots. The resulting wind erosion problems could have been lessened by no-till planting methods or inclusion of a cover crop. Because summer and fall were ideal times for planting eastern gamagrass, further studies are needed to develop a planting system for this period that protects against soil erosion. These results also suggest that fall plantings of eastern gamagrass should be deeper than 2.5 cm to ensure that dry spring conditions do not adversely affect seedling emergence.
The poorest net seedling survival was generally obtained from April and May plantings although April plantings of stratified seed produced high net seedling survival in one of the two study years. The net seedling survival from April and May plantings averaged 39 and 48% less than from the summer and fall plantings of unstratified seed in 19992000 and 20002001, respectively. In addition, the mortality from the April and May plantings could be as high or higher than that from summer and fall plantings. Although June plantings had a high net survival, most of the plants did not appear until the second growing season after planting. This left the soil exposed to erosion and weed infestation for more than 10 mo.
The summer and fall plantings of unstratified seed most closely mimicked natural conditions in which seed was dispersed in late summer and seed dormancy was naturally broken by cold, wet soil conditions during late fall, winter, and early spring (Anderson, 1985). The final net seedling survival from summer and fall plantings was similar, but there was greater seedling mortality in the summer planting of stratified seed in the first year of the study. Some plants from the summer planting emerged in the fall, especially when soil moisture was good and stratified seed was planted. These plants were at risk of being killed by the first frost, extreme winter conditions, or poor field conditions in the spring. However, this risk did not appear great enough to negatively affect the overall success of the summer plantings.
Results from the seed stratification treatments suggest that moist prechilling of eastern gamagrass seed should only be recommended for early spring plantings. Stratification nearly doubled the net seedling survival of April plantings in 19992000 but had no effect on net survival of April plantings in 20002001. Stratification did not influence net seedling survival of May or June plantings in either study year.
Seed stratification was not effective at promoting immediate seedling emergence in June plantings or the 15 Aug. 2000 planting. This suggested that stratified seed was sensitive to dry soil conditions and warm temperatures. This conclusion is further supported by the greater fall emergence in stratified than unstratified seed planted on 16 Aug. 1999 during a period of considerable precipitation. Poor stand establishment of eastern gamagrass from prolonged dry soil conditions has also been reported by Mueller et al. (2000).
The greatest net seedling survival in 20002001, at 45 to 52%, was higher than the 38 to 44% obtained in 19992000. The poorest net seedling survival in both 19992000 and 20002001 was 18 to 24%. The reasons for greater net seedling survival in 20002001 are not entirely clear. The two seed lots used in this study differed in germination percentage of stratified seed and viability (Table 2). The seed harvested in 1998 (Pete 98) and planted in the first year of the study had greater germination when seed was stratified than the seed harvested in 1999 (Pete 99) and used for the second year of the study. The viability of Pete 98 was lower than that of Pete 99, and the germination of dry seed was similar in both seed lots. Within seed lots, there was no significant difference in viability between stratified and unstratified seed.
|
There are no previous reports on the success of planting eastern gamagrass in late summer. Our data suggested that planting unstratified eastern gamagrass seed in August was generally better than planting either stratified or unstratified seed in April and May. This information will be valuable for updating eastern gamagrass planting recommendations in the U.S. Corn Belt where producers generally view spring as the most appropriate time for planting and workloads are generally less in late summer than the spring and fall.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
L. R. Gibson, E. Z. Aberle, A. D. Knapp, K. J. Moore, and R. Hintz Release of Seed Dormancy in Field Plantings of Eastern Gamagrass Crop Sci., January 31, 2005; 45(2): 494 - 502. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Rogis, L. R. Gibson, A. D. Knapp, and R. Horton Enhancing Germination of Eastern Gamagrass Seed with Stratification and Gibberellic Acid Crop Sci., March 1, 2004; 44(2): 549 - 552. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Crop Science | Vadose Zone Journal | |||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Soil Science Society of America Journal | ||||
| Journal of Plant Registrations | Journal of Environmental Quality |
The Plant Genome | |||