Agronomy Journal Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (19)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Johnston, A. M.
Right arrow Articles by Riveland, N. R.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow Articles by Johnston, A. M.
Right arrow Articles by Riveland, N. R.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Johnston, A. M.
Right arrow Articles by Riveland, N. R.
Related Collections
Right arrow Crop Rotation Systems
Right arrow Dryland Cropping Systems
Right arrow Canola
Right arrow Sunflower
Right arrow Other Oil Crops
Right arrow Production Agriculture
Agronomy Journal 94:231-240 (2002)
© 2002 American Society of Agronomy

SYMPOSIUM PAPERS

Oilseed Crops for Semiarid Cropping Systems in the Northern Great Plains

Adrian M. Johnston*,a, Donald L. Tanakab, Perry R. Millerc, Stewart A. Brandtd, David C. Nielsene, Guy P. Lafondf and Neil R. Rivelandg

a Potash and Phosphate Inst. of Canada, 12-425 Pinehouse Dr., Saskatoon, SK, Canada S7K 5K2
b USDA-ARS, Northern Great Plains Res. Lab., Box 459, Mandan, ND 58554
c Montana State Univ., Dep. of Land Resour. and Environ. Sci., P.O. Box 173120, Bozeman, MT 59717-3120
d Agric. and Agri-Food Can., Box 10, Scott, SK, Canada S0K 4A0
e USDA-ARS, Cent. Great Plains Res. Stn., 40335 Country Rd. GG, Akron, CO 80720
f Agric. and Agri-Food Can., Box 760, Indian Head, SK, Canada S0G 2K0
g North Dakota State Univ., Williston Res. Ext. Cent., 14120 Hwy. 2, Williston, ND 58101-8629

* Corresponding author (ajohnston{at}ppi-ppic.org)

Received for publication December 1, 2000.

    ABSTRACT
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
Oilseed crops are grown throughout the semiarid region of the northern Great Plains of North America for use as vegetable and industrial oils, spices, and birdfeed. In a region dominated by winter and spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L. emend. Thell.), the acceptance and production of another crop requires that it both has an agronomic benefit to the cropping system and improve the farmers' economic position. In this review, we compare the adaptation and rotational effects of oilseed crops in the northern Great Plains. Canola (Brassica sp.), mustard (B. juncea and Sinapis alba L.), and flax (Linum usitatissimum L.) are well adapted to cool, short-season conditions found on the Canadian prairies and northern Great Plains border states of the USA. Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) and safflower (Carthamus tinctorius L.) are better adapted to the longer growing season and warmer temperatures found in the northern and central Great Plains states. Examples are presented of how agronomic practices have been used to manipulate a crop's fit into a local environment, as demonstrated with the early spring and dormant seeding management of canola, and of the role of no-till seeding systems in allowing the establishment of small-seeded oilseed crops in semiarid regions. Continued evaluation of oilseed crops in rotation with cereals will further expand our understanding of how they can be used to strengthen the biological, economic, and environmental role of the region's cropping systems. Specific research needs for each oilseed crop have been recommended.


    INTRODUCTION
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
OILSEED CROPS ARE GROWN throughout the semiarid region of the northern Great Plains of North America for use as vegetable and industrial oils, spices, and birdfeed. In a region dominated by winter and spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), the acceptance and production of another crop requires that it both has an agronomic benefit to the cropping system and improves the farmers' economic position. Given that most oilseed crops have an indeterminate growth habit, adaptation is influenced by tolerance to high temperature and drought stress and by crop management to take advantage of optimum environmental conditions for flowering and seed fill. The increasing area of oilseed crop production is an indication of the success of plant breeders and agronomists in developing suitable cultivars and production methods in this semiarid region (Table 1).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 1. Harvested area of oilseed crops common to both the USA and Canada, 1988 and 1998 (FAO Stat., 1999).

 
While soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] is the major oilseed crop produced in the USA, canola is the dominant oil crop in Canada. The cool climatic conditions characteristic of the Canadian prairies provide an ideal environment for Brassica spp. oilseeds and flax (Table 2) while the climate found in the USA is better suited to the warm season crops like soybean and sunflower. In the northern Great Plains, soybean is a relatively new crop finding a place in semiarid cropping systems with the development of early maturing, low heat–unit cultivars (Miller et al., 2002). As a result, the vast majority of soybean production in both the USA and Canada occurs in wetter regions east of the Great Plains. However, for the other oilseed crops listed in Table 1, the majority of production occurs within the northern Great Plains.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 2. Climatic attributes of selected locations throughout the northern Great Plains.{dagger}

 
Diversification within cereal-based cropping systems can be critical to breaking pest infestations that are common with monoculture (Bailey et al., 1992, 2000; Elliot and Lynch, 1995; Holtzer et al., 1996; Krupinsky et al., 2002). Results of crop rotation studies in the Great Plains revealed that where oilseeds are adapted, their inclusion in rotation with cereals could increase net returns and reduce risk through improved production stability (Lafond et al., 1993; Dhuyvetter et al., 1996; Zentner et al., 2002). In addition, the yield of wheat was increased when following oilseeds in rotation, confirming that monoculture systems are the least effective means of optimizing wheat production (Lafond et al., 1992; Brandt and Zentner, 1995; Anderson et al., 1999).

The use of minimum and no-till seeding systems has been found to provide an effective means of controlling soil erosion in various regions of the Great Plains (Black and Power, 1965; Lindwall and Anderson, 1981). Improvements in seed yield with conservation tillage have been reported as a result of increased levels of plant-available water throughout the soil profile in the spring (Aase and Reitz, 1989; Brandt, 1992; Lafond et al., 1992) and increased water use efficiency due to favorable microclimate conditions created by standing stubble (Cutforth and McConkey, 1997). Some oilseed crops are small seeded, requiring good surface soil moisture for seed germination and crop establishment, as is effectively provided in direct-seeding systems in the northern Great Plains. As a result, adoption of conservation tillage management not only reduces soil loss by erosion, but also can facilitate extending the crop rotation and allowing for diversification of the crops grown. Economic success with a diversified crop rotation has been reported to be improved with the implementation of conservation tillage practices, such as minimum and zerotillage (Lafond et al., 1993; Rossetti et al., 1999; Zentner et al., 2002).

The objective of this review is to summarize information on the adaptation and production potential of some oilseed crops in dryland rotation with cereals in the northern Great Plains. Data has also been included from Akron, CO. Although located in the central Great Plains, it has similar climatic conditions to the northern Great Plains because of its high elevation. The oilseed crops of interest include canola, flax, mustard, sunflower and safflower. Soybean, while an oilseed, has been addressed in an associated review of grain legumes by Miller et al. (2002). Information will be presented from a variety of locations, representing a wide range of environmental conditions (Table 2).


    CANOLA
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
The oilseed genus Brassica, including canola and mustard, is part of the cruciferous family of crops. Cruciferous crops are widely adapted and cultivated around the world for human consumption, as a spice, and for livestock feed (Downey et al., 1974). Native to Asia and the Mediterranean region, rapeseed (B. napus and B. rapa) oil was originally used mainly as a lamp oil, with limited use in cooking. Rapeseed was first grown in North America to increase its production for marine oil during World War II. After the war, plant-breeding efforts in Canada resulted in improvements in the fatty acid composition of the oil (reduction of erucic acid) and a marked reduction in the level of glucosinolates in the meal. Together, these two improvements have made rapeseed the world's third most important vegetable oil, after soybean and palm (Elaeis guineensis Jacq.) oil (Downey and Rimmer, 1993). These modifications to the oil and meal of rapeseed led to the development of the name canola as a means of distinguishing the edible oil quality rapeseed from industrial quality oil (high erucic acid). Extraction of seed oil is high, with average oil content of 42% and a protein content of approximately 21% (DeClercq and Daun, 1999a).

Canola is cultivated widely on the northern Great Plains as a spring crop because sufficient winter hardiness has not yet been developed. The spring growth habit also fits well for canola as a summer crop in rotation before winter wheat in the coolest parts of the central Great Plains (Nielsen, 1997, 1998a).

Crop Water Use
Field assessment of B. napus indicates that it is capable of extracting water from depths of 114 to 165 cm (Table 3). The shallow measurement of 114 cm was an actual root observation and more accurately represents rooting depth than the deeper estimates, which were based on water extraction. Nielsen (1997) reported that while neutron scatter measurements found that canola extracted water to depths of 165 cm, 92 to 95% of the growing season water use of the crop came from the surface 119 cm of soil profile. Brassica spp. have a taproot system giving the crop access to deep water and nutrients (Downey et al., 1974). When grown in semiarid regions, the rooting characteristics of canola require adequate subsoil moisture to sustain the crop during flowering and seed filling. In those areas of the northern Great Plains where growing season water deficit is high, canola should be grown on summer fallow rather than continuous crop. Root growth rates for canola were greater than several other spring crops in a multiyear study at Swift Current, SK, more quickly depleting soil moisture reserves, and thus sooner becoming dependent on rainfall to sustain growth (Angadi et al., 1999b).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 3. Estimated rooting depth for canola, flax, safflower, and sunflower grown at select locations across the northern Great Plains.

 
In the semiarid region of the Canadian prairies, seed yield response to water use from trials conducted at Swift Current and Scott, SK, indicated little difference between B. napus and B. rapa (Table 4). Once the minimum water use of approximately 127 mm was achieved, seed yield increased at a rate of 6.9 to 7.2 kg ha-1 mm-1. While the base water use was higher at Akron, CO, so was the conversion efficiency at 7.7 kg ha-1 mm-1, resulting in similar water use–yield predictions between these two studies separated by 10 degrees of latitude. In the subhumid regions of the Canadian prairies, canola has been shown to have even higher water use efficiency, at 8.3 to 11.4 kg ha-1 mm-1, reflecting the lower air temperatures and lower moisture deficits in this region (Johnston et al., 1996). Thus, water use efficiency is partially a function of crop adaptation.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 4. Estimated seed yield response to crop water use for canola, mustard, flax, safflower, and sunflower grown at select locations across the northern Great Plains.

 
Canola is a cool-season crop, with the duration of flowering having a strong influence on final seed yield (Nuttall et al., 1992; Brandt and McGregor, 1997; Angadi et al., 1999b). Heat stress during flowering of a canola crop can prematurely end flowering, resulting in limited seed set after the accumulation of large amounts of dry matter. Optimal daytime temperatures during flowering of 28°C for B. rapa and 20°C for B. napus indicate considerable difference in tolerance to air temperature between species (Angadi et al., 1999b). Nuttall et al. (1992) reported that a 3°C rise in maximum daily temperature (21–24°C) during flowering in July and August resulted in a 430 kg ha-1 decline in canola seed yield. Similar negative effects on seed yield have been observed with water stress during flowering and seed filling (Stoker and Carter, 1984; Nielsen, 1997). Water stress on the crop at flowering negatively influenced the formation of pods and seed size, resulting in lower final seed yield. Together, growing season precipitation and air temperature have been found to be good indicators of canola yield potential (Nuttall et al., 1992; Brandt and McGregor, 1997). Brandt and McGregor (1997) reported that the yield of canola on summer fallow at Scott, SK, was found to be closely related to temperature during flowering and early seed development while precipitation from early seed development through seed filling is essential to achieving full yield potential (see Eq. 1).


[1]
where Precip (mm) = 21 June–20 Aug. (B. napus R2 = 0.83; B. rapa R2 = 0.82) and Temp (°C) = 15 June–15 Aug. mean daily temperature (B. napus R2 = -0.58; B. rapa R2 = -0.52).

This relationship indicates that for each degree rise in mean daily temperature, the yield of B. napus declines by 188 kg ha-1 and B. rapa by 217 kg ha-1. This indication of greater heat sensitivity for B. rapa contrasts with the observations in controlled environment conditions by Angadi et al. (1999a). Also, for each millimeter increase in precipitation, there is a corresponding 5.9 kg ha-1 yield increase with B. napus and 3.3 kg ha-1 yield increase with B. rapa, indicating a marked difference in water use sensitivity, contrasting with the equations presented in Table 4. Given that Brandt and McGregor (1997) used a common measurement period for their water use assessment and that B. rapa starts and finishes flowering 2 wk before B. napus, they may have introduced some bias into their evaluation of these crops.

Canola Management in Rotation
Including canola in rotation with wheat can have a positive effect on wheat yield. Brandt and Zentner (1995) reported that spring wheat yields were 24% higher on canola stubble than when grown on wheat stubble in a continuous wheat rotation at Scott, SK. At Melfort, SK, wheat yields were 30% higher when grown following canola than following wheat (Zentner et al., 1986). The influence of the canola crop in breaking plant disease [Septoria spp. and tan spot (Pyrenophora tritici-repentis)] buildup in the rotation was suggested as the main benefit derived from the preceding canola crop. In southern Alberta, winter wheat yields were increased by 25% when grown on canola vs. winter wheat stubble (Larney and Lindwall, 1994).

Tillage studies with canola have found that the crop is well suited to no-till seeding (Lindwall et al., 1994). Canola seed yield on no-till ranged from 1 to 14% higher than on conventional tillage. In drier regions, the maintenance of surface soil moisture with no-till has improved establishment of small-seeded crops like canola, attested by numerous observations by agronomists. In addition, the high water use requirements of canola can benefit from any additional water stored in the profile of no-till fields and may have increased water use efficiency from the microclimate of standing cereal stubble (B. McConkey, personal communication, 1999).

Ludlow and Muchow (1990) pointed out in a review that the ability to match key phenological growth period of a crop to a less stressful growth period in the growing season can be an effective means of avoiding the negative impact of heat and drought stress. Seeding date has been found to be a very important management tool in minimizing the negative impact of high temperature and moisture stress during the critical flowering and seed-filling periods in canola. Delaying canola planting past mid-April to early May has been shown to result in final seed yields that were 22 to 38% lower than late fall or early spring (Johnson et al., 1995; Kirkland and Johnson, 2000; Brandt et al., 1999). In North Dakota, the reduction in canola yield with delayed seeding was attributed to fewer pods per plant, leading to a lower harvest index (Johnson et al., 1995). Research on the Canadian prairies reported that when freezing temperatures were recorded with early planting dates, they did not negatively affect crop survival as the young seedlings appear tolerant to cold stress if acclimated (Kirkland and Johnson, 2000). A combination of factors, including cultivars, stage of development, pattern and duration of freezing temperatures, surface residue cover, and proximity of the seedlings to the soil surface, all play a role in the reaction of the seedlings to freezing temperatures.

In Saskatchewan, where winter soil temperatures generally never rise above freezing, Kirkland and Johnson (2000) have taken the early seeding of canola one step further and evaluated dormant seeding of canola in the fall just before soil freeze-up. This dormant-seeded canola is ready to begin growth as soon as temperature and moisture conditions permit in the following spring. The researchers report that relative to the traditional mid-May seeding date, late-April and fall dormant seeding increased canola yields by 44 and 34%, respectively. While crop establishment with dormant seeding is usually never as good as that achieved with spring seeding, the adaptable nature of the canola crop allows it to compensate for a thin stand through increased branching. Additional advantages of dormant seeding included earlier crop flowering (25 d), windrowing (18 d), and harvesting (19 d) (Kirkland and Johnson, 2000).


    MUSTARD
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
There are two species of mustard produced commercially in North America, Sinapis alba (white or yellow mustard) and B. juncea (brown and oriental mustard) (Forhan, 1994). As one of the first crops domesticated by man, the value of mustard as a spice rapidly spread it along the trade routes of the world. Before World War II, when mustard supplies to North America were disrupted, mustard was grown primarily in Western Europe. Similar to canola, mustard is a cool-season crop well suited to short growing season environments (90–110 d). While originally grown in the western USA, the crop is now primarily produced in the semiarid regions of western Canada (Table 1). Mustard production is used principally for human consumption as dry (40%) and prepared (60%) products (Forhan, 1994). While B. juncea is still grown as an edible oilseed in some parts of the world where strong-flavored oil is in demand, this is minor compared with the spice and condiment use for the crop.

Crop Water Use
Information on the water use characteristics of mustard was reported in recent research by Brandt et al. (1999), which included both B. juncea and S. alba. They report that B. juncea is very similar to canola in its conversion of water into seed yield (Table 4). However, while S. alba requires less water to establish its minimum seed yield, it also has much lower seed production per unit of water use relative to B. juncea. Angadi et al. (1999b) reported that B. napus and B. juncea were similar in their water use characteristics, and as a result, they concluded that despite its reputation as a drought-tolerant crop, mustard was no better adapted to semiarid regions than canola. In fact, the high water use characteristic and deep rooting pattern of the Brassica species of canola and mustard make them better suited than spring wheat or field pea (Pisum sativum L.) for production on summer fallow in semiarid regions (Brandt and McGregor, 1997). Given that summer fallow is no longer part of many cropping systems in semiarid regions, positioning canola in rotation following low water-use, shallow-rooted crops and optimizing water conservation with no-till seeding may be required to achieve successful production.

Optimum daytime air temperature for maximizing yield of B. juncea was similar to that of B. rapa, close to 28°C, and higher than the 20°C optimum for B. napus (Angadi et al., 1999a). Subjecting Brassica species to a high-temperature stress during the flowering stage of development using a temperature of 35 to 15°C (day and night, respectively) reduced the seed yield of B. juncea by 34% and B. rapa by as much as 93%. Brassica napus and S. alba both flowered with fewer accumulated heat units when seeded early rather than late (Miller et al., 1998a). Delayed seeding of S. alba resulted in the largest proportional (30%) reduction in seed yield among 12 cereal, oilseed, and pulse crops grown in a seeding date study at Scott and Swift Current, SK. For both B. juncea and S. alba, the reduction in seed size was equal in proportion to the reduction in pod density.

Mustard Management in Rotation
Little research has been conducted into the management of mustard in rotation with cereals in the northern Great Plains. In one cropping sequence study at Swift Current, SK, B. juncea did not increase seed yield of spring wheat significantly over that of continuous spring wheat though a small increase (0.5 protein units) in wheat grain protein was observed (Miller et al., 1998a). During one of eight site-years of that study, volunteer mustard seedlings competed strongly with spring wheat at the seedling stage, reducing wheat yield by 49% compared with continuous spring wheat, despite complete control with herbicide application within the recommended window. Given that mustard has a water use, rooting depth, and growth and development pattern similar to canola, it is likely to provide cropping system effects similar to canola (Angadi et al., 1999b). As discussed for canola above, optimizing the yield of Brassica sp. oilseeds in semiarid environments will depend on the timing of water and high-temperature stress relative to crop flowering and seed formation.


    FLAX
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
Flax is an ancient crop belonging to the family Linaceae. Reports of its production go back to 3000 BC in Babylon (Flax Council of Canada, 1998). Cultivated flax consists of two main types, harvested for seed and harvested for fiber. In North America, primarily the oilseed type is grown, and flax production dates back 400 yr when Louis Hebert, the first farmer in Canada, brought it to New France. With time, flax production expanded westward and southward into the Great Plains. Flax oil is high in linolenic fatty acid (45–60%), making it a very effective drying agent. Although it is an edible oil, it is used primarily for industrial purposes, such as in the production of paints and oil-based coverings and in the manufacture of linoleum flooring (Flax Council of Canada, 1998). Linseed oil also offers important nutritional benefits because of the high levels of omega-3 fatty acids. Oil extraction in flax averages 44%, and the meal has an average protein content of 23% (DeClercq and Daun, 1999b). Recent plant-breeding achievements have led to the development of a new flax type called ‘Solin’, which is a name used for flax with low (<5%) linolenic acid in the oil (Dribnenki and Green, 1995). Solin, which responds agronomically as regular flax, is being developed exclusively for the edible oil market. In North America, all flaxseed is grown in the Great Plains region, with 35% of world production in Canada and 4% in the USA (Table 1).

Crop Water Use
Relative to the other oilseed crops, flax is a shallow-rooted crop (Table 3). Research on flax water use and extraction from the soil has shown that flax will extract 90% or more of plant-available water from the 0- to 60-cm soil layer (Lafond, unpublished data, 1998). In agreement, Campbell and Zentner (1996) showed that flax grown on fallow often conserved more water in the 60- to 120-cm soil layer than did spring wheat. Seed yield response to water use from trials conducted at Swift Current and Scott, SK, indicates little difference between flax and B. napus at the same location (Table 4). Once the minimum water use of approximately 127 mm was achieved, seed yield increased at a rate of 7.6 kg ha-1 mm-1. However, at Indian Head, SK, 12 yr of water use (WU) data with flax gave a very poor relationship with seed yield [Yield (kg ha-1) = 1.9 (WU + 532 mm); r2 = 0.06]. This poor relationship at this higher-yielding location indicates that something other than water is influencing the seed yield response of flax (Lafond, unpublished data, 1998).

The shallow rooting behavior of the flax crop makes it well adapted to the improved moisture conditions of the surface soil found in no-till production systems (Lafond et al., 1992). The benefits of no-till production were demonstrated over a wide range of growing conditions, i.e., from hot and dry to cool and moist conditions (Lafond and Derksen, 1996). In fact, flax was shown to have greater water use efficiency under no-tillage (5.4 kg ha-1 mm-1) relative to conventional tillage (4.9 kg ha-1 mm-1).

Flax Management in Rotation
Although flax has been grown for a long time on the Canadian prairies and in the northern Great Plains of the USA, few rotational studies have included it (Lafond et al., 1992). Campbell and Zentner (1996) reported that flax conserved soil NO3 and water below the 60-cm soil depth compared with spring wheat though it inexplicably failed to provide a rotational benefit to a subsequent wheat crop compared with continuous spring wheat. Soil under flax stubble dries and warms sooner than that under wheat stubble, and it is possible that timeliness of water use was compromised due to a common date for spring tillage operations, which had to be delayed until the wheat stubble was sufficiently dry. It has also been recommended that flax should not be grown after legumes or potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) because of the potential for infection from Rhizoctonia spp. bacteria (Flax Council of Canada, 1998). While the recommendations have never been substantiated, it is believed that flax grown after alfalfa does exceptionally well in subhumid regions of the Canadian prairies. Other studies that have examined flax from a crop rotation basis have revolved around seeding flax into canola stubble. These studies have shown that when young volunteer canola seedlings are tilled just before the seeding of flax, yield reduction is experienced, supposedly as a result of indole glucosinolates in the vegetative material inhibiting germination (Vera et al., 1987). However, this effect was muted and even eliminated when flax was seeded directly into canola stubble as in a no-till production system (Gubbells and Kenaschuk, 1989). A survey of the Manitoba Crop Insurance Database has revealed that the yields of spring wheat were generally higher following flax than following canola or field pea (Bourgeois and Entz, 1996). Compared with canola, this can be explained in part by the fact that the shallow-rooting behavior of flax would favor the deeper-rooting crops like wheat because of extra moisture and nutrients conserved below the 60-cm soil layer.


    SUNFLOWER
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) is well suited to warmer regions of the northern Great Plains. The cultivated sunflower is native to North America and consists of two types: (i) confectionary types, used for human consumption and bird food, and (ii) oilseed. Sunflower is a tall (100–180 cm) plant and produces seed with an oil content of 40% or more. The long-season growth habit of sunflower (95–130 d) makes it best suited to areas with a long frost-free period and high growing-season heat units. A wide range of sunflower cultivars are available, each with specific heat unit requirements. Sunflower cultivars range from 1140 to 1400 growing degree days using a 7°C base temperature (Robinson, 1971). Data from northeast Colorado with the same base temperature showed a growing degree-day requirement ranging from 1485 to 1595 (Nielsen, unpublished data, 1999). Most of the growing degree-day differences among cultivars occur during the period from emergence to floral initiation.

Crop Water Use
Sunflower is a deep-rooted crop that requires 10 to 30 d more to mature than cereals, making it a high water-use crop. Plant rooting depths of 120 to 269 cm have been reported (Table 3). Jaafar et al. (1993) found that sunflower in Kansas was rooting to a depth of 269 cm, with 87 to 96% of the roots observed in the surface 165 cm of the soil profile. Nielsen (1998a) also found that sunflower in northeastern Colorado extracted water to a depth of 165 cm and that it showed very uniform water extraction to this depth. Unlike canola, which developed a deeper and more prolific root system in a dry vs. wet growing season, sunflower was very consistent in its rooting depth and water extraction regardless of the growing season conditions (Nielsen, 1998a). On loam and silt-loam soil types, sunflower has been shown to be capable of extracting soil water to a lower matric potential than corn (Zea mays L.), proso millet (Panicum miliaceum L.), and winter wheat (Unger, 1990; Nielsen, unpublished data, 1995).

Work in Colorado indicated that sunflower seed yield was less responsive to water than canola (Table 4) (Nielsen, 1998a). Similar results were reported in work on early maturing open-pollinated, short-stature sunflower in a comparative trial with B. juncea at Swift Current, SK (Miller et al., 1998a). Miller et al. (1998b) concluded that short-stature sunflower used water inefficiently relative to mustard and, as such, may not be as well suited as other oilseed crops in semiarid regions. However, subsequent research with a dwarf hybrid sunflower, slightly later in maturity than the short-stature sunflower, showed water use efficiency equal to B. juncea (Miller et al., 1998a). Direct comparisons of water use efficiency between sunflower, a warm-season plant, and cool-season oilseeds are difficult to make accurately in the highly variable climatic conditions of the northern Great Plains. The much longer growth cycle of sunflower causes a higher likelihood of anthesis and seed fill occurring during summer drought. However, midsummer rainfall received after cool-season oilseeds have ceased growth can be converted efficiently to seed yield by sunflower. Also, the seeding date of sunflower is often delayed weeks to months after Brassica spp., indicating that these crops utilize the environment in completely different patterns. This may be because sunflower is a warm-season broadleaf and most of the preanthesis growth occurs during periods of high evapotranspiration demand, whereas B. juncea is a cool-season broadleaf and most of its vegetative growth occurs during the low evapotranspiration part of the growing season.

Sunflower Management in Rotation
Crop management trials in Colorado have found that sunflower fits well into cereal-based crop rotations but should not be grown more than once every 3 or 4 yr due to persistence of the damaging plant disease phoma (Phoma macdonaldii Boerma) (Anderson et al., 1999). The high water use of sunflower reduced the yield of subsequent crops in rotation, especially during dry years. Results from a crop rotation study at Akron, CO, showed reduced average yields of winter wheat when the crop was grown following sunflower in rotation compared with rotations without sunflower (Nielsen et al., 1999). Yield reductions were much larger in a 3-yr rotation (wheat–sunflower–fallow) than in 4-yr rotations (wheat–corn–sunflower–fallow or wheat–millet–sunflower–fallow). In wet years, the yield-reducing effect of the previous sunflower crop was not evident in the 4-yr rotations but still manifested itself in the 3-yr rotation.

To reduce the potential for crop failure after sunflower, good soil and water conservation practices need to be used, and a drought-tolerant crop should be planted that uses water efficiently. Nielson (1998b) showed that much of the detrimental effect of the high soil water extraction by sunflower could be offset when sunflower stalks are left standing after harvest. In years with normal to above-normal snowfall in the central Great Plains, 6 to 15 cm of soil water recharge can occur while concurrently providing adequate protection against wind erosion (Nielsen and Aiken, 1998).

Wind erosion potential and soil water evaporation are minimized when no-till or reduced-till weed control and sunflower-planting practices are employed to maintain previous crop residues on the soil surface during the sunflower growing season. In recent years, there has been increased interest in minimum- and no-till sunflower production practices (Blamey et al., 1997). Maintaining surface residue from the previous crop results in reduced soil erosion and evaporation and increased rainfall infiltration and soil water storage. Maintaining surface residue using no-till helped suppress evaporation and increased sunflower seed yield 16% compared with conventional tillage (Norwood, 1999).

The maintenance of surface crop residues in sunflower rotations helped to reduce or prevent the buildup of certain weed species. Weed populations often proliferate within the open canopy of sunflower, but combining cultural practices, such as delayed seeding, narrow rows, banded fertilizer, and increased plant population, has improved weed control (Tanaka and Anderson, 1999).


    SAFFLOWER
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
Safflower is a member of the Compositae or Asteraceae family and provides three products: an edible oil, meal, and birdseed. Historically, safflower was grown for its flowers, with the florets being used for coloring and flavoring foods, for making dyes, and as medicines (Mundel et al., 1992). It is one of humanity's oldest crops and was usually grown in small plots for a grower's personal use. Safflower is a thistle-like annual herbaceous plant with long, sharp thorns that is grown mainly in arid and semiarid areas of the world. Currently, it remains a minor crop, with world seed production around 800000 t annually (Gyulai, 1996).

The crop was introduced into North America as early as 1899 from its origin in the Middle East and South Asia. Safflower was initially tested in the USA in 1925 as a new oilseed crop and was commercially grown in the Great Plains beginning in the late 1950s (Knowles, 1958). Oil content of safflower seed ranges from 35 to 40%. There are two types of safflower cultivars: those producing oil high in oleic or monounsaturated fatty acid and those high in linoleic polyunsaturated fatty acid (Berglund et al., 1998). After oil extraction, the seed meal has a protein content of about 24% (Hoag et al., 1969). Safflower seed that is uniformly bright white in color or lightly striped can be marketed as birdseed.

Crop Water Use
Safflower generally is considered a daylength-neutral, long-day plant that needs at least 1400 degree days (5°C basis) to reach maturity. Miller et al. (2001) used a very early maturing cultivar of safflower (Saffire) to calculate degree-day requirements of 1430 to 1480 at Swift Current, SK, concluding that maturity requirements for safflower generally were too great for that location. Plants have a deep taproot that can extend to a depth of 220 cm (Table 3) and xerophytic spine attributes that contribute to good drought and heat tolerance (Dajue and Mundel, 1996). Safflower will not survive in standing water for even a few hours during warm weather (Mundel et al., 1997). Therefore, good estimates of yield per unit of water are difficult to determine. Research at Mandan, ND, found that the water use efficiency of safflower ranged from 1.2 to 5.1 kg ha-1 mm-1 for crops seeded mid-May or early June (Alessi et al., 1981). Studies conducted by Hang and Evans (1985) using a line-source irrigation method determined that safflower's water use efficiency was 8.45 kg ha-1 mm-1 at 50 cm of irrigation. In north-central Montana, Brown and Carlson (1990) collected water use data in safflower cultivar trials over 10 yr, generating a rainfed yield–water use equation of:

Water use was estimated based on soil water extraction to an assumed 213-cm soil depth, with an estimated 254 mm of plant-available water. The Brown and Carlson (1990) equation appears similar to the high end of the range reported by Alessi et al. (1981). In general, safflower grown in the northern Great Plains of the USA yields best in areas where along with good soil moisture at seeding, growing season precipitation (May through August) is in the 15- to 25-cm range, with at least 75% of the precipitation occurring before the end of July. The flowering and pollination of safflower can be severely reduced by rainy days or days with excessive dew and high humidity. Plant diseases such as alternaria (Alternaria carthami) and bacterial blight also flourish under these conditions and can cause major yield reductions.

Safflower in Rotations
Including safflower in wheat-based rotations can improve use of deep soil water and N (Black, 1993). The long growing season required by the crop permits deep root growth, enabling safflower to use water and nutrients from a greater soil depth than crops with a shorter growing season. Because safflower uses more soil water and requires a longer growing season than small grain crops, it and other crops of similar rooting depth should be grown in 3-yr or longer rotations to reduce potential failure of other crops in a rotation. In areas that have dryland saline-seep problems, safflower can be used in rotation to use surplus water from recharge areas to prevent the expansion of saline seeps (Mundel et al., 1992). Control of grassy weeds in safflower can benefit subsequent small grain crops in a rotation. Conversely, broadleaf weed control in small grains can also benefit safflower production because few herbicides are registered for use in this minor crop.


    OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS IN THE NORTHERN GREAT PLAINS
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
The successful use of oilseed crops to diversify cropping systems in the northern Great Plains has been demonstrated in this review. The oilseeds canola, mustard, and flax are well adapted to cool, short-season conditions found on the Canadian prairies and northern border states of the USA. Sunflower and safflower are better adapted to the longer growing season and warmer temperatures found in the northern and central Great Plains states. However, agronomic practices can manipulate a crop's fit into a local environment, as demonstrated with the early spring and dormant seeding management of canola and the role of no-till seeding systems in allowing the establishment of small-seeded oilseed crops in semiarid regions. Continued evaluation of oilseeds in rotation with cereals will further expand our understanding of how these crops can be used to strengthen the biological, economic, and environmental role of the region's cropping systems. Specific research needs for each oilseed crop are suggested.

Canola and mustard crops are capable of producing large amounts of crop biomass under conditions of good early season moisture and warm temperature. However, low-water and high-temperature stress conditions during flowering and seed filling can result in poor seed formation and a very low harvest index. There is a need to continue to evaluate canola and mustard cultivars under high-stress environments to determine if there are plant types better suited to these environments, with conservative growth habits that are better matched to soil water constraints. Further research is required across the semiarid regions of the northern and central Great Plains to evaluate the full impact of alternative seeding dates on the suitability of Brassica sp. oilseeds in cropping systems. This type of seeding-date manipulation may greatly expand the production area of these cool-season oilseed crops.

The authors' understanding of the water use characteristics and yield potential of flax is very poor. In the more humid areas of the northern Great Plains, there is a need to understand why the positive relationship between seed and water use becomes very weak as available water and water use increases. However, likely the greatest need for research in flax is to develop a better understanding of yield formation, with an emphasis on which management practices have the greatest influence on yield and how this knowledge can be used in the development of new flax cultivars.

Future research needs to continue to define where sunflower has the best fit in the overall crop production system. The role of a deep-rooted crop like sunflower in utilizing subsoil moisture and nutrients has not been fully exploited in cropping systems where both deep- and shallow-rooted crops are grown.

Safflower seedlings lack the vigor displayed by many other crops (Berglund et al., 1998). Spring stand establishment is a major problem in the northern Great Plains because of inadequate seed–soil contact, soil crusting, lack of adequate soil moisture in the seedbed, or seedling diseases. Early spring planting can also be a problem because of cool soil temperatures. Future research areas for safflower include improving seedling vigor, improving seed dormancy to minimize sprouting at harvest, increasing seedling cold tolerance, developing seeding techniques, and other management practices to improve spring stand establishment, including those improving resistance to seedling disease. Areas such as weed control, rotations, and value-added products are major research topics currently being pursued. But one research area that the safflower industry sorely needs is marketing research and creation of a national organization to promote safflower as a very healthy, edible oil; viable industrial oil, and food for birds.

The successful inclusion of oilseed crops in cereal-based cropping systems has been shown in this review to have positive agronomic and economic impacts. Genetic improvement in oilseed crop yields will continue to make them economically competitive with cereals. Evaluation of oilseed crops through agronomic management will ensure their role as a diversification option in Great Plains cropping systems.


    NOTES
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 
Saskatoon Res. Cent. Publ. 1421.


    REFERENCES
 TOP
 NOTES
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 CANOLA
 MUSTARD
 FLAX
 SUNFLOWER
 SAFFLOWER
 OILSEED CROP RESEARCH NEEDS...
 REFERENCES
 




This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
Agron. J.Home page
V. D. Zheljazkov, B. A. Vick, M. W. Ebelhar, N. Buehring, B. S. Baldwin, T. Astatkie, and J. F. Miller
Yield, Oil Content, and Composition of Sunflower Grown at Multiple Locations in Mississippi
Agron. J., May 7, 2008; 100(3): 635 - 642.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Agron. J.Home page
C. Chen, G. Jackson, K. Neill, D. Wichman, G. Johnson, and D. Johnson
Determining the Feasibility of Early Seeding Canola in the Northern Great Plains
Agron. J., July 13, 2005; 97(4): 1252 - 1262.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Crop Sci.Home page
S. V. Angadi, H. W. Cutforth, B. G. McConkey, and Y. Gan
Yield Adjustment by Canola Grown at Different Plant Populations under Semiarid Conditions
Crop Sci., July 1, 2003; 43(4): 1358 - 1366.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow