Published in Agron J 91:613-621 (1999)
© 1999 American Society of Agronomy
677 S. Segoe Rd., Madison, WI 53711 USA
Agronomy Journal 91:613-621 (1999)
© 1999 American Society of Agronomy
TOBACCO PRODUCTION
Relationships among Soil Nitrate, Leaf Nitrate, and Leaf Yield of Burley Tobacco
Effects of Nitrogen Management
Charles T. MacKowna,
Steven J. Crafts-Brandnerb and
Tommy G. Suttonc
a USDA-ARS, Grazinglands Research, 7207 W. Cheyenne St., El Reno, OK, 73036 USA
b USDA-ARS, Western Cotton Research Lab, Phoenix, AZ 85040-8830 USA
c Dep. of Agronomy, Univ. of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40546-0091 USA
cmackown{at}grl.ars.usda.gov
Received for publication August 21, 1998.
 |
ABSTRACT
|
|---|
Burley tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) requires large amounts of fertilizer N to produce high yields of cured leaf with the quality traits demanded by buyers. However, excessive N use produces air-cured leaves with undesirable levels of NO-3, is uneconomical, and is environmentally unsound if substantial levels of residual soil NO-3 remain following harvest. Effects of N fertilizer on relationships among leaf yield, NO-3 concentrations of air-cured leaves, and soil NO-3 levels were investigated in 1991 and 1992 at two locations near Lexington, KY. Fertilizer N was broadcast at 0 to 448 kg ha-1 (56-kg increments) before transplanting or banded at 168 kg ha-1 about 5 wk after transplanting. Soils were a well-drained Maury silt loam (fine, mixed, mesic Typic Paleudalf) and a moderately well-drained Captina silt loam (fine, silty, siliceous, mesic Typic Fragiudult). Cured leaf yield and lamina NO-3 increased with increasing amounts of broadcast fertilizer N. Yield increased 3.7% with banded N, compared with an equivalent amount of broadcast N. Banding N also increased the NO-3 level of cured leaf lamina by 37% for bottom leaves and 17% for middle leaves; top leaves were unaffected. Soil mineral N (NH+4 + NO-3) was proportional to the amount of broadcast N applied, and NO-3 levels in the upper 30 cm of soil declined during the growing season. For predicted maximum leaf yields of 90%, critical soil mineral N values of 46 and 88 mg kg-1 (for Captina and Maury soils, respectively) were estimated from average mineral N concentrations in the upper 30 cm at 3 and 5 wk after transplanting. Early-season soil NO-3 testing to predict the NO-3 level of cured leaf lamina was not useful; a nearly twofold difference in lamina NO-3 was observed among years when soil NO-3 levels were equivalent. At 280 kg N ha-1, a rate commonly recommended for burley tobacco, as much as 37 mg NO-3N kg-1 soil was found in the upper 30 cm of soil following harvest. Decreasing the amount of fertilizer N broadcast just before transplanting to 168 kg N ha-1 caused a 10% reduction in yield, a 37 to 65% decrease in lamina NO-3, and about a 60% decrease in residual soil NO-3 at harvest. Better N management can reduce both the NO-3 level of cured leaves and the amount of residual NO-3 following harvest.
 |
INTRODUCTION
|
|---|
INSUFFICIENT N substantially reduces the yield and quality of burley tobacco (Miner and Sims, 1983). Because burley tobacco is a high-value cash crop, producers are more likely to overfertilize their crop with N. Such practices lead to the production of cured leaves with undesirable levels of NO-3 (Broaddus et al., 1965; Brunneman and Hoffmann, 1982; MacKown et al., 1984). Excessive use of N fertilizer is economically unfavorable, because incremental increases in yield diminish with increasing amounts of N applied (Miner and Sims, 1983), and it could lead to detrimental effects on the quality of soil and water resources. Burley tobacco fields that are heavily fertilized with N often have soil acidity-induced Mn toxicity problems (Hiatt and Ragland, 1963; Sims and Atkinson, 1973; Miner and Sims, 1983), and could have high concentrations of soil NO-3, which can lower the quality of ground and surface waters. Even when recommended fertilizer practices are used, substantial residual soil NO-3 has been observed at harvest (Zartman et al., 1976; MacKown et al., 1990).
The amounts of N fertilizer recommended for tobacco fields following grass sod range from 224 to 336 kg N ha-1, with an additional 56 kg N ha-1 recommended for continuous tobacco (Anonymous, 1998). Typically, with well-drained soils, the entire amount of N fertilizer is broadcast up to 4 wk before transplanting. Sometimes an additional N application is banded 4 to 5 wk after transplanting. For coarse-textured or poorly drained soils, split applications of one-third of the total N before transplanting and two-thirds after transplanting are recommended, to minimize fertilizer N losses (Sims and Wells, 1985; Nesmith et al., 1993). Banding the entire amount of N at 5 wk after transplanting, when the last cultivation occurs, improves fertilizer N recovery on well-drained and moderately well-drained soils without adversely affecting yield or quality (MacKown and Sutton, 1997). Split N applications are probably more appropriate, however, because they are likely to reduce the risk of low yield if rainfall delays or prevents applying the entire amount of N at 5 wk.
With appropriate N management practices, it may be possible to limit the accumulation of NO-3 in leaves, optimize fertilizer N use, and reduce the potential degradation of soil and water resources. Leaf yield, market grading, and value responses of burley tobacco to fertilizer N have been well documented. However, information generated from a comprehensive experiment designed to determine the effect of N additions on the relationships between leaf yield, cured leaf NO-3 levels, and amounts of available and residual soil NO-3 is lacking. Our primary objective was to evaluate these relationships. Emphasis was placed on the changes in soil NO-3 following pre-transplant broadcast applications of fertilizer N. Secondarily, we sought to test our hypothesis that banding all N at the time of last cultivation and before the onset of rapid crop growth would not alter cured leaf NO-3 concentration or have a negative effect on leaf yield.
 |
Materials and methods
|
|---|
Experiments were conducted in 1991 and 1992 near Lexington, KY, on two farms belonging to the University of Kentucky. At Spindletop Research Farm, plots were located on a well-drained Maury silt loam. At Eden Shale Research Farm the soil was a moderately well-drained Captina silt loam. Monthly climate data for Spindletop Farm were obtained from the University of Kentucky Agricultural Weather Center (1998) and from daily observations recorded at Eden Shale Farm.
During the fall of 1990 at Spindletop Farm, tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.) was incorporated by moldboard plow, agricultural lime was applied to raise the soil pH to 6.6, and a winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cover crop was planted. In the spring of 1991, the wheat cover crop was plowed to prepare the site for planting tobacco. A two-year-old stand of red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) hay was plowed in the spring of 1991 to prepare the Eden Shale site for tobacco. For the year preceding the 1992 experiments, the sites were planted with tobacco that was fertilized with 290 kg N ha-1 at Spindletop and 250 kg N ha-1 at Eden Shale. Winter wheat cover crops were planted on these sites in the fall of 1991 and plowed in the spring of 1992 to prepare the sites for tobacco. Soil tests for available P (Bray 1) were very high at both sites and K was low to medium at Spindletop and very high at Eden Shale (data not shown). Before transplanting tobacco, K2SO4 fertilizer (325 kg K ha-1 in 1991; 260 kg K ha-1 in 1992) was broadcast and disked into the soil at Spindletop. Burley tobacco `TN86' transplants were set in mid to late May in rows spaced 1.02 m apart, with about 0.49 m between plants. Recommended cultural and management practices were followed (Nesmith et al., 1993), except as regards N levels and timing, which were treatments in the experiment. The tobacco crop was harvested mid-August to early September (87 to 107 d after transplanting). Plots were disked and winter cereal cover crops were planted before mid-October, as recommended for erosion control and residual N recovery from tobacco fields (Nesmith et al., 1993).
Nitrogen Treatments
Ten N treatments were arranged in a randomized complete block design, with six replications. Nine amounts of NH4NO3 (0 to 448 kg N ha-1 in 56-kg increments) were broadcast by hand and lightly disked into the soil surface 1 or 2 d before transplanting. The 10th N treatment was of 168 kg N ha-1 of NH4NO3 hand-applied in bands about 10 cm deep and 30 cm to each side of a row at about 5 wk after transplanting. Plots were 15.2 m long and five rows wide, except in 1991, when they were six rows wide at Eden Shale.
Soil and Plant Sampling
The top 30 cm of soil was sampled from 0 kg N ha-1 treated plots at transplanting and from a subset of the broadcast N treatments (0, 56, 112, 168, 280, and 392 kg N ha-1) at 3 and 5 wk after transplanting and at harvest. From each plot, about 30 cores (1 cm diam.) were collected and combined for analysis. Six soil profile cores (3 cm diam., 90 cm deep) from each plot were collected from the 0, 112, 280, and 392 kg N ha-1 treatments about 2 wk after planting fall cover crops and during mid to late April the following spring. These cores were subdivided into 30-cm increments and combined by depth for each plot. Soil samples were sieved in the field to pass a 2-mm screen, placed in ice chests, and returned to the lab for immediate extraction.
Cured leaf yields were based on a sample of 40 to 50 plants harvested from the interior rows of each plot and air-cured in tobacco barns located at each farm. A subsample of air-cured leaves from each plot were grouped into upper, middle, and bottom stalk positions and analyzed for NO-3.
Nitrate and Ammonium Analysis
Duplicate subsamples of the field-moist soil were extracted with 1 M KCl (w/v, 1/10) by shaking vigorously for 1 h. Another subsample was used for gravimetric determination of soil water content. Extracted NO-3N was measured colorimetrically following microbial dissimilatory reduction to NO-2 by a manual adaptation of an automated method (Lowe and Gillespie, 1975) or by an automated flow injection analyzer with a Cd reduction column. Both procedures would include NO-2, if present. Extracted NH+4N was measured colorimetrically with an automated flow injection analyzer equipped with a diffusion unit to trap NH3 in a colored pH-sensitive solution (Tecator AB, 1984).
Plant tissues were dried to constant weight in a forced-air oven at 60°C, weighed, and ground to pass a 1-mm screen. Duplicate subsamples of the ground tissue were extracted with deionized water for 1 h at 97°C. Extracted NO-3N was measured using the methods described for soil NO-3.
Statistical Analysis
Analysis of variance and regression procedures (JMP version 3.2.2; SAS Inst., 1994) were used to analyze the data. Locations and years were initially treated as fixed effects in the analysis of variance model used to evaluate the response of cured leaf yield and NO-3 concentration. A multivariate-fitting platform with repeated measures in space was used to analyze lamina NO-3 data for the three stalk positions. When the sphericity test was significant, the GeisserGreenhouse adjusted univariate test was used to evaluate the F-statistic determined for the contrast response design. This data analysis approach with repeated measures in time was used also for soil NO-3 determinations during the growth of the tobacco crop. A multivariate analysis with a compound response design (repeated measures in time and space) was used to analyze data collected for fall and spring residual NO-3 in the soil profile.
 |
Results and discussion
|
|---|
From May 1991 through April 1993, nearly 2270 mm of precipitation would normally have been received at Spindletop Farm (Fig. 1)
. The measured amount at Spindletop Farm (2430 mm) for this period was about 7% greater than the expected normal precipitation; at Eden Shale Farm, the measured amount of precipitation was 2000 mm, which is nearly 12% less than the normal for Spindletop Farm. Deviations from expected normal monthly precipitation totals occurred during the intervals of tobacco growth (mid-May to late August or early September) and after harvesting (Fig. 1). In all cases, the amounts of precipitation at Spindletop Farm equaled or exceeded those of Eden Shale Farm during the growth of tobacco and between harvest and collection of soil profile samples for NO-3 (Table 1)
.

View larger version (43K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1 Monthly precipitation from May 1991 through April 1993 at Spindletop and Eden Shale farms and the long-term (19611990) average for Spindletop Farm
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 1 Periodic amounts of precipitation measured during growth of tobacco and two post-harvest time intervals corresponding to collection of soil profile samples for residual NO-3 following tobacco harvest
|
|
Leaf Yields
Increases in the yield of cured leaf diminished with increasing amounts of broadcast N fertilizer applied and incorporated into the soil surface just before transplanting (Fig. 2)
. The leaf yield response patterns differed each year; the range and maximum yields in 1991 were greater than those in 1992. Within a year, the leaf yield response patterns to broadcast N were not significantly different at the two locations, but overall the yields on the well-drained silt loam at Spindletop Farm were greater than those on the moderately well-drained silt loam at Eden Shale Farm. The range in yield responses for the soils used in this study are similar to those of the well-drained and moderately well-drained soils used to produce tobacco in central and western Kentucky (Atkinson and Sims, 1973).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2 Burley tobacco cured leaf yield response to pre-transplant broadcast applications of fertilizer N on silt loam soils at Spindletop Farm (Maury, well-drained) and at Eden Shale Farm (Captina, moderately well-drained). Yields are expressed as field weights (0.2 kg moisture kg-1 dry wt. of leaf). Where greater than symbol size, error bars indicate ±1 SE of the mean
|
|
Leaf yields were slightly increased (3.7%, P = 0.023) when 168 kg N ha-1 was banded at 5 wk after transplanting rather than broadcast just before transplanting (Table 2)
. The interaction effects of application method with year and location effects, however, were not significant for leaf yield.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 2 Yield and lamina NO-3 concentration of cured leaves of burley tobacco fertilized with 168 kg N ha-1 broadcast-applied just before transplanting or band-applied about 5 wk after transplanting
|
|
An overall estimate can be made of the additional broadcast N needed to achieve the 3.7% yield increase due to banding N. The predicted equivalent yield increase associated with banding N was used with an overall regression equation of the yield response curve to solve by iteration for the independent variable of broadcast N. Using this approach to match the effect of banding 168 kg N ha-1, nearly 44 kg N ha-1 of additional broadcast N fertilizer applied just before transplanting would have been required.
Banding N fertilizer also offers additional benefits. In an earlier study with 15N-depleted fertilizer N, banding N at about 5 wk after transplanting increased fertilizer N recovery 6 to 17% more than an equivalent amount of broadcast N applied just before transplanting (MacKown and Sutton, 1997). The last opportunity to use a tractor to cultivate tobacco fields without damaging the crop usually occurs at about 5 wk after transplanting. Producers could combine the last cultivation operation with a band application of the entire amount of N, but excessive rainfall might delay or prevent the use of farm equipment to apply the N required for good leaf yield. Using one or more early cultivations to band all or part of the fertilizer N could reduce this risk. Banding N at any time within the first 5 wk after transplanting should not adversely affect leaf yield, and banding N earlier than 5 wk after transplanting may offer some of the fertilizer N recovery benefit obtained when the entire amount of N is banded at 5 wk after transplanting (MacKown and Sutton, 1997).
Soil Mineral Nitrogen
The concentration of mineral N (NH+4 + NO-3) in the top 30 cm of soil at 3 and 5 wk after transplanting increased linearly with increasing amounts of N fertilizer broadcast and incorporated into the soil surface just before transplanting (data not shown). The contribution of NH+4 to the early-season total mineral N was small when the level of broadcast N was less than 280 kg ha-1, but NH+4N contributed up to 38% of the total soil mineral N for broadcast applications greater than or equal to 280 kg N ha-1 (data not shown). Apparently, early-season microbial NH+4 oxidation capacity of these soils approached a maximum at about 140 kg NH+4N ha-1. Differences in soil NO-3 levels at 3 and 5 wk after transplanting were small compared with the declines that occurred from 5 wk after transplanting until about 8 to 10 wk later just after harvest (Fig. 3)
. Zartman et al. (1976) found that N accumulated by burley tobacco grown on the well-drained Maury soil of Spindletop Farm was proportional to the soil solution concentration of NO-3 and the upper 30 cm of soil contributed about 90% of the total N accumulated. The onset of the decreased level of soil NO-3 (Fig. 3) corresponds to the period of greatest N demand required to sustain the linear phase of rapid crop growth and nutrient accumulation that begins at about 5 wk after transplanting (Atkinson et al., 1977).

View larger version (30K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3 Changes in soil NO-3 levels within the top 30 cm of soil receiving pre-transplant broadcast applications of fertilizer N. Error bars indicate the LSD (0.05)
|
|
Leaching and denitrification processes during the last 8 to 10 wk of the tobacco crop may have contributed to the declines of NO-3N in the top 30 cm of soil, but in some cases the contribution of these processes does not appear to be important. Just after harvesting tobacco that was broadcast fertilized with 280 kg N ha-1 (within recommended N application range; Nesmith et al., 1993), the top 30 cm of soil contained as much as 75 kg NO-3N ha-1 at Spindletop Farm in 1992 and 150 kg NO-3N ha-1 at Eden Shale Farm in 1991 (data not shown; estimated from soil NO-3 and bulk densities). At Spindletop Farm in 1991 and Eden Shale Farm in 1992, the amount of residual NO-3 detected at tobacco harvest in plots broadcast fertilized with 280 kg N ha-1 was not significantly different (P = 0.05) from that of plots not fertilized with N (11 and 5 kg N ha-1 at Spindletop and Eden Shale Farms, respectively). The high levels of soil NO-3 detected at Eden Shale following the 1991 tobacco harvest could have been derived in part from mineralization and nitrification of the legume residue incorporated in the spring of 1991. Available crop residue N should have been less from the nonlegume cover crops used at Spindletop Farm and at Eden Shale in 1992.
An unexpected discrepancy between the level of residual soil NO-3 just after harvest and leaf yield at Eden Shale Farm was observed for broadcast N applications of 280 and 392 kg N ha-1 (compare Fig. 2 and Fig. 3). In 1991, residual soil NO-3 for these treatments exceeded those in 1992, yet 1991 leaf yields exceeded those of 1992. This apparent discrepancy may be partially resolved by considering two factors. First, the preceding legume cover crop in 1991 probably contributed more N than the winter cereal cover crop in 1992. Second, precipitation during the 1992 tobacco-growing season substantially exceeded that of 1991 (Table 1). Even when recommended N fertilizer practices are used, substantial residual soil NO-3 can exist at harvest (Fig. 3; Spindletop 1992 and Eden Shale 1991).
The compound multivariate analysis of postharvest residual NO-3 levels in the soil profile revealed that the depth x date interaction among the N fertilizer x year x location effect was significant (P = 0.001). At mid to late October of each year (about 7 to 9 wk after harvest), concentrations of residual NO-3N in the top 30 cm of the soil tended to equal or exceed that at the 60- to 90-cm depth (Fig. 4)
. By mid to late April 1992, levels of NO-3N in the top 30 cm of soil were substantially less, but at lower depths the levels of NO-3N were as great or greater than the previous fall levels (Fig. 4). In April 1993, the levels of soil NO-3N were uniformly low (<3.0 mg kg-1) throughout the profile at Spindletop Farm, and <2.6 mg kg-1 in the top 60 cm to <13.2 mg kg-1 at the 60- to 90-cm depth at Eden Shale.

View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4 Postharvest fall and spring residual soil NO-3 in the soil profile of well-drained (Spindletop Farm) and moderately well-drained (Eden Shale Farm) silt loam soils. Soil collection dates are referenced to days after transplanting (DAT). Where greater than symbol size, error bars indicate ±1 SE of the mean
|
|
Apparent net increases in the levels of residual soil NO-3 present in the upper 30 cm of soil were often observed from just after harvest until mid to late October (compare Fig. 3 and Fig. 4). These net increases, probably the consequence of N mineralization, occurred even though rainfall during this period was as much as 178 mm (Table 1) and could have caused leaching of NO-3 below 30 cm. Decreases in the NO-3 levels of the upper soil profile between the fall and spring soil sample collections were undoubtedly due in part to NO-3 uptake by the winter cover crops planted after harvesting the tobacco (Karraker, 1930; Karraker and Bortner, 1937). Previously reported data of cover crop N accumulation at these locations showed the importance of using winter wheat to capture residual fertilizer and soil derived N (MacKown and Sutton, 1997). Even when cover crops are used, leaching of soil NO-3 apparently can occur. Net increases in the levels of soil NO-3 below 30 cm following the 1991 tobacco crop reveal that, for broadcast N applications of 280 kg N ha-1 or more, NO-3 was leached from the upper 30 cm of soil. Leaching of soil NO-3 probably occurred following the 1992 tobacco crop as well. For example, in the fall of 1992 at Eden Shale Farm, the upper 90 cm of soil of plots fertilized with 280 kg N ha-1 contained nearly 200 kg N ha-1, which decreased to about 30 kg N ha-1 by the time the cover crops were sampled in mid-April (estimated from Fig. 4). This difference of 170 kg N ha-1 exceeds by nearly twofold that expected to be recovered by a winter wheat cover crop (estimated from MacKown and Sutton, 1997).
Cured Lamina Nitrate
A significant sphericity test was found when the multivariate analysis of lamina NO-3 using leaf stalk position as a repeated measure was transformed into the univariate model. The adjusted univariate test was significant (P = 0.015) for the contrast design interaction of leaf stalk position with the between-subject model factor of N fertilizer x year x location. Concentrations of NO-3 in the lamina of cured leaves increased with increasing amounts of broadcast N fertilizer incorporated into the soil surface just before transplanting (Fig. 5)
. This leaf NO-3 response to fertilizer N level is consistent with earlier reports (Atkinson and Sims, 1973; Broaddus et al., 1965). Positive slope linear relationships between lamina NO-3 and broadcast N fertilizer were observed, except for 1991 at Eden Shale, where increases in lamina NO-3 concentrations diminished with increasing amounts of N fertilizer (Table 3)
. Levels of lamina NO-3 decreased sequentially from the bottom to the top stalk positions at both locations and for each year. Previous reports (Bowman, 1972; Broaddus et al., 1965; Hamilton et al., 1982) support this observation and document that the concentration pattern of reduced N increases from the bottom to top stalk positions (Bowman, 1972; Broaddus et al., 1965; Hamilton et al., 1982).
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 3 Regression equations of lines in Fig. 5 describing the relationships between NO-3 concentrations (µmol g-1) of cured leaf lamina sampled from three stalk positions and amount of broadcast fertilizer N (kg ha-1) applied to burley tobacco just before transplanting
|
|
The univariate model of the transformed multivariate analysis of lamina NO-3 concentration revealed that the leaf stalk position effect and the interaction of this effect with N application method were significant (P < 0.01). Band application of 168 kg N ha-1 at about 5 wk after transplanting produced leaf lamina with greater NO-3 concentration (26%, averaged across all stalk positions) than when the same amount of N was broadcast and incorporated into the soil surface just before transplanting. When leaf lamina NO-3 analysis of variance was determined for each position, the effect of N application method was found to significantly increase the lamina NO-3 concentration of leaves sampled from only the bottom and middle stalk positions (Table 2). This effect of band application of the entire amount of N at 5 wk after transplanting is undesirable because the formation of nitrosamines in cigarette smoke increases as the level of NO-3 increases in cured tobacco leaves (Tso et al., 1975; Sims et al., 1979; Brunneman and Hoffmann, 1982). However, comparing NO-3 levels of leaf lamina obtained with banded N to those of an equal yield of leaf produced with broadcast N (212 kg N ha-1) reveals that only the bottom leaves of plants treated with banded N would have greater NO-3 concentrations. The overall (across locations and years) average lamina NO-3 concentration of cured bottom leaves from plants broadcast fertilized with 212 kg N ha-1 would be 11% more (estimate calculated from Table 3). In contrast, the NO-3 concentration of leaves from the middle would have been 8% less, and those from the top stalk position would have been 14% less than leaves from equal yielding plants grown with N broadcast just before transplanting. The single application of banded N apparently was associated with a rate of NO-3 accumulation by the lower canopy leaves that greatly exceeded the assimilation rate of absorbed NO-3 into reduced N products.
Relationships of Soil Mineral Nitrogen to Cured Leaf Yield and Lamina Nitrate
Increases in the cured leaf yields of burley tobacco diminished with increasing average concentrations of mineral N (NH+4 + NO-3) measured in the top 30 cm of soil before the onset of rapid crop growth (Fig. 6)
. For both locations, equations with significant quadratic components gave the best fit for the relationship between these two variables. Expressing yields relative to the predicted maximum yields derived from the regression equations of Fig. 2 did not improve the relationships between soil mineral N and yield (data not shown). Site-specific effects and broad confidence intervals could limit the value of early-season soil mineral N tests for accurately predicting fertilizer N requirements to achieve a desired yield (Fig. 6). The CateNelson approach (Cate and Nelson, 1972) has often been used to identify critical soil NO-3 values for the nonlinear response of relative corn (Zea mays L.) yield to pre-sidedress NO-3 concentration of soils in the Northeast and Atlantic Coast regions (Bock and Kelley, 1992; Magdoff et al., 1990; Sims et al., 1995). Linearplateau or quadraticplateau models also have been used to determine the plateauthreshold value that corresponds to the critical NO-3 value of soils from the Midwest and Atlantic Coast (Binford et al., 1992; Meisinger et al., 1992). In some cases, N recommendations for corn were improved when yield potentials of soils were considered and the soil NO-3 test values were within the N responsive range (Bundy and Andraski, 1995). Using a CateNelson graphical approach to minimize the number of low soil mineral Nhigh leaf yield and high soil mineral Nlow leaf yield observations for data presented in Fig. 6, the early-season (35 wk after transplanting) estimated critical soil mineral N value for a 90% maximum yield (location average predicted from Fig. 2) was 88 mg kg-1 at Spindletop Farm and 46 mg kg-1 at Eden Shale Farm. These values may be useful in predicting whether an early-season addition of fertilizer N will increase leaf yield of burley tobacco.

View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6 Relationships between yield of burley tobacco cured leaf and average soil mineral N (NH+4 + NO-3) in the top 30 cm of soil measured at about 3 and 5 wk after transplanting. Dashed lines represent 95% confidence intervals that include both the variability of regression estimates and the variability of the observations, making them suitable for prediction intervals. Horizontal and vertical lines represent CateNelson graphic interpretations of soil mineral N critical values at 90% maximum yield as predicted for each location from data presented in Fig. 2
|
|
The relationship between the average level of soil NO-3 measured at 3 and 5 wk after transplanting and the concentration of NO-3 in cured leaf lamina varied depending on year, location, and stalk position of leaves (Fig. 7
; Table 4)
. At equivalent soil NO-3 levels, lamina NO-3 levels were about twofold greater in 1992 than 1991. While the yields of 1991 were greater than those of 1992, a dilution effect due to yield differences was insufficient to entirely account for differences in lamina NO-3. Even though the lamina NO-3 response patterns to early-season soil NO-3 were similar for the two locations, year-to-year differences preclude accurate prediction of cured lamina NO-3 levels solely from measurements of soil NO-3 in the upper 30 cm of soil. Differences in lamina NO-3 of leaves sampled from different stalk positions tended to be greater as the 3 and 5 wk average soil NO-3 level increased. These effects probably reflect the seasonal decline of soil NO-3 as the crop grew and the newest leaves in the upper canopy expanded.

View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7 Relationships between lamina NO-3 concentrations of cured leaves sampled from three stalk positions of burley tobacco and average of soil NO-3 in the top 30 cm of soil measured at about 3 and 5 wk after transplanting. Dashed lines represent upper and lower boundaries enclosing the range of 95% confidence intervals that include both the variability of regression estimates and the variability of the observations for the three leaf positions sampled
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 4 Regression equations of lines in Fig. 7 describing the relationships between NO-3 concentrations (µmol g-1) of cured leaf lamina sampled from three stalk positions and the average concentration of NO-3N (mg kg-1) in the top 30 cm of soil sampled at about 3 and 5 wk after transplanting burley tobacco
|
|
 |
Summary and conclusions
|
|---|
Cured leaf yields, soil NO-3 levels, and the concentration of NO-3 in cured leaf lamina were affected by broadcast applications of N fertilizer and varied with year and location. Early-season added N should increase yields if average soil mineral N levels between 3 and 5 wk after transplanting are less than 46 mg kg-1 (moderately well-drained soil of Eden Shale) or 88 mg kg-1 (well-drained soil of Spindletop) in the upper 30 cm of soil. Leaf yield with a band application of 168 kg N ha-1 at about 5 wk after transplanting was slightly (3.7%) more effective than applying the same amount of N just before transplanting. Banding N at about 5 wk after transplanting resulted in an undesirable increase in the NO-3 concentration of leaves harvested from lower stalk positions. Use of early-season soil NO-3 tests to predict the NO-3 level of cured leaf lamina does not appear feasible; among years, nearly twofold differences in lamina NO-3 levels were observed when soil NO-3 levels were equivalent.
Continued refinements of diagnostic tests to improve the N management of burley tobacco are warranted. Early-season soil mineral N tests could be used to better manage the N fertilizer requirements of burley tobacco by identifying fields that are likely to respond to added fertilizer N. With better N management, decreases in the NO-3 level of cured leaves and the amount of residual NO-3 following harvest should be possible. For example, 37 to 65% decreases in lamina NO-3 and about a 60% decrease in residual soil NO-3 are associated with a 10% decrease in cured leaf yield of tobacco receiving 168 kg N ha-1 of fertilizer broadcast just before transplanting. However, using current N management practices and tobacco cultivars, it is unlikely that growers will accept lower yields to produce low-nitrate tobacco unless leaf buyers support a leaf nitrate monitoring program and provide an economic incentive.Cate Nelson 1965; SAS Institute 1994; Tecator 1984; University of Kentucky Agricultural Weather Center 1998
 |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
|
|---|
We gratefully acknowledge the technical assistance received from Bettie Jones. Joseph W. Wyles, Farm Manager, provided precipitation data for Eden Shale Farm. Also, James Cohlmeyer and Rosalyn Williams, who were supported by the USDA-ARS Research Apprenticeship program for high school students, and José R. Graxirena-Cotto, who was supported by the University of Kentucky summer internship program for undergraduate minority students, provided assistance.
 |
NOTES
|
|---|
Joint contribution of the USDA-ARS and Kentucky Agric. Exp. Stn. Journal no. 98-06-131.
 |
REFERENCES
|
|---|
- Anonymous. 1998. 19981999 Lime and fertilizer recommendations. Ky. Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull. AGR-1.
- Atkinson W.O., Sims J.L. Nitrogen composition of burley tobacco: II. Influence of nitrogen fertilization, suckering practices, and harvest date on yield, value, and distribution of dry matter among plant parts. Tob. Sci. 1973;17:63-66.
- Atkinson W.O., Bush L.P., Sims J.L. Dry matter and nutrient accumulation in burley tobacco. Tob. Sci. 1977;21:81-82.
- Binford G.D., Blackmer A.M., Cerrato M.E. Relationships between corn yields and soil nitrate in late spring. Agron J. 1992;84:53-59.
- Bock, B.R., and K.R. Kelley. 1992. Predicting N fertilizer needs for corn in humid regions. Natl. Fert. and Environ. Res. Ctr., Tenn. Valley Authority, Muscle Shoals, AL.
- Bowman D.R. Chemical composition of leaf lamina and midrib portions of burley tobacco during latter stages of growth and curing. Tob. Sci. 1972;16:6-8.
- Broaddus G.M., York J.E., Moseley J.M. Factors affecting the levels of nitrate nitrogen in cured tobacco leaves. Tob. Sci. 1965;9:149-157.
- Brunneman K.D., Hoffmann D. Pyrolytic origins of major gas phase constituents of cigarette smoke. Recent Adv. Tob. Sci. 1982;8:103-140.
- Bundy L.G., Andraski T.W. Soil yield potential effects on performance of soil nitrate tests. J. Prod. Agric. 1995;8:561-568.
- Cate R.B., Jr., Nelson L.A. A rapid method for correlation of soil test analyses with plant response data. Raleigh: Soil Testing Series Tech. Bull. 1. N.C. State Univ, 1965.
- Hamilton J.L., Bush L.P., Lowe R.H. Nitrate concentration changes during senescence and air curing of burley tobacco. Tob. Sci. 1982;26:133-137.
- Hiatt A.J., Ragland J.L. Manganese toxicity of burley tobacco. Agron. J. 1963;55:47-49.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Karraker P.E. Time of seeding small grain after tobacco and saving nitrate. J. Am. Soc. Agron. 1930;22:890-895.
- Karraker P.E., Bortner C.E. Nitrogen leaching in soil on the experiment station farm at Lexington. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 1937;2:393-398.
- Lowe R.H., Gillespie M.C. An Escherichia coli strain for use in nitrate analyses. J. Agric. Food Chem. 1975;23:783-785.[Web of Science][Medline]
- MacKown C.T., Eivazi F., Sims J.L., Bush L.P. Tobacco-specific N-nitrosamines: Effect of burley alkaloid isolines and nitrogen fertility management. J. Agric. Food Chem. 1984;32:1269-1272.
- MacKown C.T., Sutton T.G. Recovery of fertilizer N applied to burley tobacco. Agron. J. 1997;89:183-189.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- MacKown C.T., Sutton T.G., Bush L.P. Nitrogen compositional changes in xylem exudate and leaves of burley tobacco. Crop Sci. 1990;30:133-138.
- Magdoff F.R., Jokela W.E., Fox R.H., Griffin G.F. A soil test for nitrogen availability in the northeastern United States. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 1990;21:1103-1115.
- Meisinger J.J., Bandel V.A., Angle J.S., O'Keefe B.E., Reynolds C.M. Presidedress soil nitrate test evaluation in Maryland. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1992;56:1527-1532.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Miner G.S., Sims J.L. Changing fertilization practices and utilization of added plant nutrients for efficient production of tobacco. Recent Adv. Tob. Sci. 1983;9:4-76.
- Nesmith, W.C., G.A. Duncan, B. Maksymowicz, G. Palmer, W.M. Snell, L. Townsend, and W.B. Witham. 1993. Tobacco in Kentucky. Ky. Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull. ID-73.
- SAS Institute. JMP statistics and graphics guide. Version 3.1. Cary, NC: SAS Inst, 1994.
- Sims, J.L., and K.L. Wells. 1985. Liming and fertilizing burley tobacco. Ky. Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull. AGR-49.
- Sims J.L., Atkinson W.O. Accumulation of dry matter and nitrogen content of burley tobacco growing in fertilizer-induced acid soil. Agron. J. 1973;65:762-765.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Sims J.L., Atkinson W.O., Benner J.F. Nitrogen fertilization and genotype effects on selected constituents of smoke from all-burley cigarettes. Tob. Sci. 1979;23:11-13.
- Sims J.T., Vasilas B.L., Gartley K.L., Milliken B., Green V. Evaluation of soil and plant nitrogen tests for maize on manured soils of the Atlantic Coastal Plain. Agron. J. 1995;87:213-222.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Tecator A.B. Determination of ammonia nitrogen by flow injection analysis and gas diffusion. Höganäs, Sweden: Application Note AN 50/84. FOSS Tecator AB, 1984.
- Tso T.C., Sims J.L., Johnson D.E. Some agronomic factors affecting N-dimethylnitrosamine content of cigarette smoke. Beitr. Tabakforsch. 1975;8:34-38.
- University of Kentucky Agricultural Weather Center. 1998. Kentucky weather and climate information: Climatology: Monthly climate data [online]. Available at http://wwwagwx.ca.uky.edu/ (accessed July 1998).
- Zartman R.E., Phillips R.E., Leggett J.E. Comparison of simulated and measured nitrogen accumulation in burley tobacco. Agron. J. 1976;68:406-410.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
C. T. MacKown, S.J. Crafts-Brandner, and T. G. Sutton
Early-Season Plant Nitrate Test for Leaf Yield and Nitrate Concentration of Air-Cured Burley Tobacco
Crop Sci.,
January 1, 2000;
40(1):
165 - 170.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
|
 |
|